Final essay
April 21, 2013
Word Doc: Unknown by SK
Unknown
By Sofia Khiskiadze
“Thinking: the talking of the soul with itself.”
– Plato
The blood rushes,
The breathing hardens,
The head feels light;
It’s a smoking gun.
“Where do thoughts go?” He asked.
Nowhere. They disappear into thin air.
They seep through my hands,
They lead the way;
They keep me back.
I surrender. I close my eyes.
I am blinded; I am kidnapped.
Only darkness from here on out, as if there was any light to begin with.
The only color I see is black. The only color I see is red.
White spots. Blue spots.
No spots. I am trapped.
“Where do thoughts go?” He asks.
They are within us. They prove we exist.
“I think, therefore I am.” said Descartes.
Where would I be without thoughts? Who would I be?
Would I exist without your thoughts there to interpret me?
The eyes distort reality, so we can interpret what we see. They turn the image upside down, and then right side up; that’s how you are able to see me. What you see, therefore is not who I am. Who I am is not what you see.
–
I don’t scream. I don’t yell for help. I don’t walk around with my hands tied behind my back. I don’t have an apple stuck in my mouth to stop me from talking. The apple is bitten and it sits idle next to where I sleep. The apple is false, my knowledge transient, my knowledge limited, your knowledge nonexistent, my knowledge pointless, yours meaningful.
“Where do thoughts go? “ He asked
They are a part of us. They prove we exist. To make sure you know that I exist, I must relay some of my thoughts to you, and you must do the same for me. Existence established; knowledge shared. Your thoughts are now my thoughts, my thoughts your thoughts. Some of them anyway.
Socrates once said, “The only true wisdom is in knowing you know nothing.” People before us thought the sun revolved around the earth. That was true then, that was fact. Just like they thought the world was flat. Today, the earth revolves around the sun, moving 66,500 miles per hour.
Today I am true, I am fact. Tomorrow, my body will be food for nourishment, my bones shelter, a body in a box that no one dreams about. Tomorrow, I was dead.
Because I could not stop for Death,
He kindly stopped for me;[1]
“Where do thoughts go?” He asked.
They are within us. They make us who we are. They activate the windows to the mind. They become the silent windows to the soul. They prove we exist.
I am. I am. I am.[2] Thought the woman in the sea. She whispered it to herself, to prove that she is flesh, to prove that she is here. To prove that she is sane.
But the gas seeps through the cracks,
Engulfs the body.
Drowns out the daemons.
Stops the thoughts. Escapes the prison.
You find yourself yelling I am! I am! I am! Until you no longer are. The noise is gone. The thoughts strangled, the soul released. Your body left next to your bitten apple.
–
I am not who I think I am. My thoughts distort the past, the memory. My mirror distorts my figure, the perception. My body yells out limitations- distorted. My thoughts quickly jot them down – estranged. I am twisted; I am upside down; I am inside out; I am shattered. Yet you see me whole. The damage is done. The damage unseen. The damage is real. The damage is in my head. My head is damage. I am damage, damage is me.
The bitten apple is rotting next to my empty body.
I dreamt of a life with more sun than rain. More beauty than pain. More life than death. More land than graves. I dreamt of thoughts out of this realm, as if they could be true. As if I could capture happiness while I am a slave to my thoughts. As if the darkness will somehow disappear and the neglected cold window looking out into the world will be grazed by the warmth of the sun. As if somehow the part of me full of ditches would one day be full of flowers. As if this room in my head is not real; as if this person I have created is a façade. As if all is unknown, my knowledge zeroed out. On my bed lay a body without me in it, my eyes closed, my apple full of worms.
(The apple was never there. I was never there.)
The woman in the sea said I am. I am. I am.
The woman in the dream said. I will. I will. I will.
One day I will be.
“Is all that we see or seem
But a dream within a dream?”
– Edgar Allan Poe
Cover Letter
Dear Reader,
My goal is to confuse, to make you feel like I took you on a journey, but that you can’t figure out where the destination is. I want you as a reader to have the urge to read it twice. I want this piece to be a mirror into the conscious/ subconscious. The way I framed the essay, there is some repetition (that is intentional because we have reoccurring thoughts), there are very short sentences (reflective of fragment thoughts), there is an abundant use of quotes (the thoughts we have which stem from others) and then there is the apple and the body, which I kind of try to zoom out the image so that you can see the body laying, but it is not the part of the thought, it is the fact; its there and not there (so in my head that is what I am trying to make ‘the reality’).
I had created a draft before I wrote my proposal, then I wrote another draft after I wrote the proposal, and then I wrote one after Ely Shipley came to our class. This idea of feeling like someone but not seeing it in the mirror; this idea of memory not being stable; this idea of how others see us and how they interpret who we are. I was thinking all of this before, but I didn’t know how to format it, and after this class, it just sort of somehow clicked. My issue with this essay as it is the consistency. I am not sure if my intention is carried out through the piece, and if my reader is able to follow along. Yes my intention is to confuse, but it is also to make you understand this idea that nothing is real, our thoughts create and our thoughts destroy. We give things words like this is death and this is life and this is a thought, our language creates what we see and how we see it, and by it we are limited. There is a great quote by George Orwell from 1984, “But if thought corrupts language, language can also corrupt thought.”
In terms of format, I am not sure of the format that I have undertaken. I am not sure if I am using too many quotes, or frankly if this is even lucid enough to be read. I think I need to make sure that everything is where it needs to be and that there is consistency within this piece. This is sort of an outline of where I want this to go. The tools in terms of structure, I used really short sentences in some parts, because I wanted it to be read very quickly (i.e the damage part of the essay), there is also one part where I put a sentence within parentheses and set it off on its own. There are parts of the poem (Ie the beginning) that is structured like a poem, and it reappears in some parts. It does not necessarily rhyme, but it flows I think- it might need some work. I have not mastered any of these tools yet, but I think these tools are essential for my essay.
“Tomorrow I was dead.” Is the sentence I am most proud of. I actually googled it to see if anyone had already thought of writing that. (It was influenced by George Orwell’s 1984 where he writes, “We are the dead”.) I can’t explain exactly why I like it, but that it simply stands out in my mind because it challenges the instinct of crossing out the ‘was’ and replacing it with ‘will be’ which would be the correct tense to replace it with; this goes back to the last part of my essay where I write “I will. I will. I will. One day I will be”.
Questions:
- What was your initial gut feeling after you read this essay? (ie: Hate it/ like it/ confused/ whatever)
- Is there something you wish was different, or something you think needs to be improved on, or something that confused you?
Sincerely,
Sofia
April 29th, 2013 at 9:32 am
Hey Sofia,
My initial gut reaction to reading your draft was WOW. I absolutely loved it and I think that’s because it seems almost dark to me in way (I’m not sure if it was intended to be) and I’m very drawn to writing like that. I feel like you and I see the world in a somewhat similar way, at least based on this paper I should say.
The quotes you used in this paper fit beautifully in with the whole piece. They don’t feel forced or heavy handed at all. They helped with the flow of essay. I know in your cover letter you said you wanted this piece to be confusing but I never really found it to be confusing. It could just be me and how I think and see things that kept me from being confused as I read but I found the essay to be very clear.
My favorite part of the essay is definitely the structure. Reading it I felt as if I was reading a poem that had little breaks where you put in your thoughts (the longer paragraphs) and I think it worked really well.
The only two parts I felt that felt a little forced were:
“Where do thoughts go?” He asks.
They are within us. They prove we exist.
“I think, therefore I am.” said Descartes.
Where would I be without thoughts? Who would I be?
Would I exist without your thoughts there to interpret me?
and also,
They are a part of us. They prove we exist. To make sure you know that I exist, I must relay some of my thoughts to you, and you must do the same for me. Existence established; knowledge shared. Your thoughts are now my thoughts, my thoughts your thoughts. Some of them anyway.
In the first one I think the quote from Descartes should just be separate from the rest of that paragraph. It would be more visually appealing and it would flow better with the rest of the piece in my opinion.
In the second one I think the last sentence feels like it doesn’t belong with the rest. The paragraph seems so authoritative almost and then the last sentence feels out of place because it’s not.
Your essay is very poetic and I really enjoyed reading it. Your favorite line was “Tomorrow I was dead” and that line is great, it works well with your premise of a distorted reality. My favorite part of the paper was:
“The eyes distort reality, so we can interpret what we see. They turn the image upside down, and then right side up; that’s how you are able to see me. What you see, therefore is not who I am. Who I am is not what you see.”
I had to read that part twice because it was just so beautiful to me. My gut reaction to that paragraph was “I want that as a tattoo” haha.
I can’t wait to see your final piece.
Thank you,
Iordan
May 1st, 2013 at 8:33 am
Hey Sofia,
I absolutely loved this essay. I like the writing tools that you play with and how you jump around between writing styles and thoughts. I think that you confuse the reader as you intend to do through your writing… so good.
I love that you play with reality, about what actually exists and what we create in our own minds. I also love the incorporation of the quotes. I don’t think that it is too much; you are playing with the idea of thinking about other people’s thoughts, an Inception-like concept that I am totally feeling. I don’t think that the piece is too confusing at all. It felt more like an experience than an essay and I appreciate that.
I think that the introduction to the piece is extremely inviting and I love the poetic one-sentence style that you use. I almost wanted that again at the end, kind of coming full circle like falling into and out of a dream. It might be something that you want to play with on the next revision?
Thank you for letting me read!
Hutch
May 1st, 2013 at 12:13 pm
Sofia,
This is essay is very poetic and I really enjoyed reading it. Like Hutch, it kind of has an inception-esque feel to it.
The quotes are really powerful. I especially enjoy “The only true wisdom is in knowing you know nothing.” I always think about how much information, how many stories there are that I haven’t heard, how many people I haven’t met, and how many places I haven’t seen. There is so much to know, and so much that we will never know. It makes you wonder how significant we are in this tremendous universe. At the same time, we ourselves have our own stories that others haven’t heard, so we are part of the “known” and the “unknoown” at the same time. Weird..
This essay really makes you think about the meaning of us being here, and that’s awesome.
I would say maybe to incorporate your opinion. Somewhere in there tell why you think we’re here, or why you think we should be here. Maybe try to form a response to the ultimate “why question” because I feel this whole essay is posing a question in itself.
Excited to see the final version!
-Kris