This week I chose the chapter “Grading Has Always Made Writing Better” to read. The name of the chapter caught my attention because I find this topic very ambiguous.
This chapter mainly talks about the necessity of a grading system in education, the key point is that without grading there is no space for growing and improving your work. However, I decided to focus on a different issue of grading. For me, the problem at the heart of the chapter is that grading is not always very reliable. Your grade will most likely depend on who is grading your work, what is your relationship with this person, not to mention what kind of work this is, or what topic you chose to talk about.
After some research on Google, I found that the group that is most interested in this issue is parents. They find the grading system in schools to be very unfair, and let’s say…unpredictable. Their children come home being very disappointed and upset just because there is no explanation behind the grade they receive. They are worried that it seems almost impossible to figure out what are some of the criteria of a certain grade.
I, myself, had faced this issue many times in my life. Sometimes, I attributed the bad grade to the teacher’s incompetence instead of thinking about improving my own work…
I wonder if there is a system of grading which would provide an independent grade, meaning that it would not be aware of the relationship between student and the teacher; or a topic that was chosen, or an opinion expressed.