Capturing Communities in Words and Images:

Behind the Velvet Rope

“It is going to be an extraordinary evening,” I was told approaching one of New York’s exclusive night clubs, “she will be here tonight,” my guide continued. Dressed to impress, party patrons stood in high heel stilettos crowding the sidewalks as far as I could see. I couldn’t help but wonder whether I was going to be allowed in. I was not sure whether I could brush off the rejection in the midst of all this frenzy. “What kind of a place is this,” I asked, as I composed myself approaching ever closer to the epicenter that marked the entrance. “We know the bouncer, her name is Monica,” my friends giggled, as we trotted closer to the velvet rope. Well, Monica as I learned later, is actually Michael during the day. I assumed a peripheral role. I stood behind my guide and hoped that I would be able to cross the ephemeral line that separated the in crowd from those who could only fantasize what was going to happen tonight, in a few hours, just underneath their feet. Like an auctioneer, my guide waved a few hand gestures and the rope parted as others watched in envy. Surely, the line was about one city block long. An exchange had occurred in midst of all the hand shakes as my guide talked his way past the velvet rope. A small price to pay for what was going to be an extraordinary night at this club. It is here that I was going to find Amanda Lapore.

Unable to decipher the song, my feet felt a trembling sensation with every beet of the music. It was as if the sound was confined, like a prisoner, and was impatiently trying to find an escape. Walking down the stairs, through one endless hallway after another, I felt like I was a part of a game, finding my way to the center of a dark labyrinth. At the last turn, before opening the doors to the heart of it all, a guy in black marked my wrist. Now I have been branded- no longer an outsider of the community. With the opening of the double doors, the music once held captive, now lashed out quickly immersing the hallways with a forceful deep base echoing off of solid black walls, teasing those still walking through the labyrinth. I entered and it was immediately evident why so many would consider the wait in the cold worth their while. In fact, tonight was going to be different, extravagant, and glistening. Tonight is her birthday celebration and everyone gathered to make sure it was just that and nothing less for the ultimate Diva, the odalisque of the gay world, Amanda Lepore.

I have entered the underground life of the community where rules usually do not apply. Dodging my way through the wall-to-wall crowd, I inched my way closer to the table with exquisite champagne, exclusive crowd, and VIP written all over it. The table where Amanda Lepore was celebrating her ‘twenty-first again’ birthday. Before I was able to find the star of the night, I couldn’t help but notice the other tables. I have walked into a room full of Dionysian characters. Taking a drag and hiding the flame of the cigarettes, partygoers bathed under a cloud of smoke. “One at a time please,” I heard in the background as bathroom attendants begged the patrons entering the stalls. Exiting, some were all refreshed, while others exited all disheveled. It is as if the rules of society did not apply here. I couldn’t stop but think that some, would consider this hell, others would relinquish their every day life to escape to this underground paradise. In this world, getting tired on the dance floor doesn’t mean that the night is over, it just simply implies that it’s time for another refreshment break in the bathroom stalls.

Some may mistake this event for a costume party, but to those within the community it is a lot more than that. It is the ability to leave behind their every day life at work or school and transform themselves to be who they want to be perceived as. An average man by day, a queen at night, is the escape they are seeking. Logan, a student at a city college considers his gender to be female, while his sex male. Even though he is hesitant about a complete transformation to another sex, for now he is satisfied with just transforming his gender at night. “It is as if a wild animal in me is set free!” he remarked, as vibrated to the music. Most believe that transgenders were born with the wrong sex and they feel as if they are in the body they don’t belong in. “Every time I look in the mirror, I see just a girl,” he answered when asked about his transformation at night. It is a challenge, he described, to be accepted in the society as a transgender. However, the obstacles he has to face every day made him mature at a much faster rate than an ordinary student his age. There exists a big misconception about transgenders. Stereotypes associate their community as a life style based on drugs and diseases. Many successful businessmen, company executives who graduated top of their class from Ivy League colleges also comprise a big part of this community, as I quickly learned. Logan’s best friend, who also transforms at night, was given a full tuition at Princeton, because of his academic brilliance. He does not consider himself smart, but because he was frowned upon by the stereotypes surrounding him, he compelled himself to strenuous work that in the end resulted in his success. Logan and his best friend are one of the many examples of a false stereotype clouding the transgender community today. For some like Logan, it is a transformation from day to night to participate in the festivities of this party. For others it is an every day life and the means of making a living. Lady Gadiva, as she calls herself, transforms into a female and stays that way for days on end. She works as a bartender and an entertainer and described the strenuous effort and the many hours spent to transform. Unlike Logan, Lady Gadiva spends majority of the workweek as a female. Transgenders, such as Logan, look up to Amanda Lepore as more than just a transgender. She serves as an Icon for the transgender community, as someone who represents the ultimate success story because of her fame and public exposure.

My mission would not be complete until I meet Amanda Lepore herself. As I pushed myself through the crowd, there she was, stepping out of her VIP section and greeting her many acquaintances. As she thanked them for coming, I jumped at the opportunity to speak with Amanda. She is nothing like no other, neither a male or nor a female, but perfectly androgynous, the envy of Ganymede in the Renaissance. She appears completely content. Like Marilyn Monroe, America’s most famous sex symbol of the early twenties, Amanda Lepore will one day commemorate the ultimate transgender.

Celebrating amongst her friends was Amanda Lepore’s photogropher, Jermey Kost. He has known the birthday girl for decades and has had the opportunity to photograph her incessant transformations over the years. As he explained, she undergoes plastic surgeries almost on monthly bases. For the most part, he added, she has reached her ultimate look, and now she is only maintaining beauty with minor changes. Her appearance is ever changing and her body a work of art in progress. All of which have contributed to her timeless image. It was time to bring the cake. Like Narcissus who kneeled daily beside a lake to contemplate his own beauty, she stares at the image of herself rendered in frosting on a birthday cake, while others wondered if there is even a similarity to the Amanda today.

As this was not my first attempt to immerse myself into the transgender community, one thing became very clear over time. For the most part, majority of the events that I have attended consisted predominantly of transgenders and gay men with an absence of the heterosexual community. It is very rare that you find a straight couple in a trangender club. This event, however, was very different. The crowd was mixed, consisting of both gay and straight men, heterogeneous married couples, journalists and photographers. They were all here to see Amanda Lepore the celebrity figure, the Diva, the transgender that has been behind the lens of world renowned photographers, such as David Lachapelle. After all, to achieve her appearance she has gone through a numerous surgeries over a spam of decades, some excruciating and others that defy mother nature.

Because of all the stereotypes, most of which I discovered as being false, the transgender community is not accepted and probably will not be accepted in its entirety throughout many cultures. New York City is unique in the sense that the transgender community has incorporated well into the everyday life of a New Yorker who is more accepting of this community. It is perhaps in diverse and large metropolitan cities where their hope lies. In some countries, the very act of being a homosexual is frowned upon and in certain parts of the world it is illegal and even punishable by death. New York City with its tolerance has accepted different life choices. The people of New York City, whether they are homosexual or heterosexual, professional or nonprofessional, young or elderly, have made Amanda Lepore into a celebrity figure despite her difference. Indeed, Amanda Lepore celebrated her ‘21st again’ birthday here in New York among fans and friends, but more importantly she celebrated the victory of the transgender community.

Amanda Lepore’s Birthday

Having a title of a celebrity figure, it was hard to to capture Amenda Lepore’s undivided attention, nevertheless I was able capture her during the most significant moments of the night and have a short chat with her after the event.  Her birthday party was one of the most staggering events that I have attended. Mr. Black, one of New Yorks most discreet transgender night clubs was packed wall to wall with Amanda Lepore’s closest friends, photographers and herself sitting in the VIP section, behind the velvet ropes.

Usually transgenders are found amongst gay crowds in gay clubs. This even was different, or at least the crowd was. It was a very diverse and mixed crowd, which consisted of girls, gay and straight guys and transsexuals. Amongst the crowd were some of her closest friends, her photographers and people who belong to her community.

Even though she does not consider herself to be a transsexual, but rather just a female, she nevertheless is a figure everyone in that community looks up to. Because of her out of this world, extraordinary appearance she has attracted the worlds most renown photographers such as David LaChapelle. Jeremy Cost, a photographer whom I was fortunate enough to speak with told me that he has captured Amanda Lepores ever changing appearance as she underwent and still undergoes plastic surgeries on monthly bases. He claims that she is “ever changing and everlasting” because as her appearance incessantly changes over the years, she does not age.

A very close friend of hers, Anjela Muzzo, who is also a transvestite told me that Amanda Lepore was not just trying to become a female, but she was striving to look like no other human alive and she has accomplished just that. Her protoge was “Another version of Marilyn Monroe,” and according to her friend, she considers herself accomplished, both in terms of looks and importance. Marilyn Monroe will be always remembered as the beauty of the early nineteen twenties, perhaps Amanda Lepore will occupy the same position in the transgender community.

A snack before transforming

For some it’s every day life, for others it’s a transition between day and night. Like a Vampire by night human by day, many transgenders are able to sustain a normal life by day but change their gender at night. You would never see him like this during sunlight, he wouldn’t even show a picture of who he looks like during the day. Godiva, as she calls herself wants to keep his underground life secretive for everyone other than those in his transgender community.

A Transgender Community behind the Velvet Rope

The gender identity of an individual is a way a person perceives himself, either as a man, woman or even neither. When a person’s self-identification doesn’t match with one’s assigned sex, he or she can be categorized as a transgender. Many societies frown upon people who consider themselves transgender, because they deviate from norms excepted by most cultures and societies. Over the past century people have become more open to gays, lesbians, and the transgender communities. While it is legal in the United States to be whom you choose, however, many people still disparage on the notion of a transgender community and regard it as a taboo. In some countries, such as those in the Middle East, being a transgender is illegal and may even be punishable by death. New York City as a community, on the other hand, tends to be more liberal, culturally diverse, and in general more tolerant of the transgenders.
Over the past several decades transgender communities have formed all over New York City. Transgender icons, the celebrities amongst the transgenders, have placed much effort to developing a greater acceptance of their community by working against the taboo. Amanda Lepore is an example of such an icon. Being born a man, he was not content with his sexuality and had a very strong perception of himself as female. Born as Armand Lepore, went through numerous transformations to rid of his given sex at birth. Currently, Armand Lepore, now known as Amanda Lepore, is the most famous transgender in New York City. Behind velvet ropes, in the VIP lounges of New York’s finest clubs, Amanda Lepore represents the ultimate Diva, an odalesque of the gay world, an inspiration for some and hope for others. Most importantly, Amanda Lepore embodies a true modern day transgender icon.
I am seeking to explore that very community behind the velvet ropes. By visiting night clubs after hours, I want to seek Amanda Lepore in her element. I want to learn more about her transformations, her adventures to stardom and becoming the most famous transgender in New York City. I will also seek to find the less obvious transgenders. In other words, those who express themselves by night and act as the sex they have been given at birth by day.

Upper Esters

Field Notes:

First image: This image captures an Upper East Side toddler and his nanny. It is not rare that children in the wealthier communities are raised by their nannies. In this image you see a high-end modern stroller and a modestly dressed African American baby sitter. Even though it is just a babe, you can see the disparity of class between him and the nanny. The reason I captured this image “Out of site out of mind” is because while waiting for the light, the babysitter is lost in thoughts. Perhaps while taking care of this darling Upper East Sider she thinks of her own children and whether they are being taken care of while she is taking the baby of the affluent for a walk.

Second image: A darling Junior, born into the Upper East Side family is coming back from an expensive, private school. What I love about this image is that he is so young, yet he belongs to this upper class of people. The woman who happens to be captured in the background of this image is amazed by this lifestyle as she is looking around and is walking with astonishment. Meanwhile the junior and his mother walk confidently with a sense of belonging home.

Third image: This image portrays some of the luxuries that come along with living on the Upper East Side. Most of us take trains some try to catch taxies, however living on the Upper East Side doormen do most of the work for you to make your life as comfortable as possible. On this image a doorman found a taxi for a woman, unloaded her bags into the trunk and pampered her in every way he could in return for a couple of dollar tip. Many who belong to the community of the Upper East Side even have their own drivers waiting outside their homes. If you look on the left hand side there is an outsider observing with envy and vicariously living the life of the affluent.

Fourth image: The juxtaposition of a street vendor and a Bergdorf Goodman department store makes this image intriguing. What makes it even more unique is that a business man, who we would typically expect to find in a high end department store, was distracted from his upper class life by a street vendor. Just like some of us would venture to walk in to Berdorf Goodman to catch a glimpse of the Upper class life, he ventures in the opposite direction as he is looking through $5 silk pahminas who anyone can afford.

Fifth image: 5th Avenue has some of the most upscale stores in the world. This image captures a Louis Vuitton Store and a guy who just came out of it. He is dressed like those who live on the Upper East Side and he is holding a Louis Vuitton bag, which costs more than many of us make in a month. Moreover his attire alone costs more than some low middle class families make in a year. What strikes me the most is the red velvet and the red shirt he is wearing. The red velvet rope usually means that this is a VIP area reserved for some and restricted for average persons. Perhaps the attire he is wearing and the color of his shirt subconsciously signifies the same thing.

Last image: Upper East side is a perfect location to step out of your house and walk around in the Central Park getting away from all the hastles of the city. After a relaxing walk, one who lives there can cross the street and be back in the city that never sleeps.