The Establishment

“What seemed to be happening was that the Establishment—Republicans, Democrats, newspapers, television—was closing ranks behind Ford and Kissinger, and behind the idea that American authority must be asserted everywhere in the world.”

After Nixon left his position as president, Ford took over his seat as president. Ford had to face the chaotic events of major trends included a growing disillusionment of government, advances in civil rights, increased influence of the women’s movement and etc. All amid war, social realignment and presidential impeachment proceedings leading to the false values created by the Watergate scandal, American culture was changing by the chaotic 60’s to the uncontrollable 70’s. In the Ford years, even with Nixon gone his system still remain, his foreign policy. The establishment represented the private sector consisting of business corporations, media, political parties and etc was losing hope amid Ford’s years  because of Watergate and Vietnam. Zinn explains that the public opinion of the Establishment – the government and the military – continued to be low, unemployment and poverty were up making it similar to the depression in Ford’s years. The loss of American confidence that they had during the world wars of being a predominate power led to the from the loss of government authority and the system, the Establishment was losing faith and trust to the government as well in the 70’s. In order to fix the hopeless war in Vietnam the insert of American authority in Cambodia was to close on Ford’s and Kissinger’s system by the Establishment.

Where’s the trust?… Apparently, it’s nowhere to be found.

Honeywell Corporation

“How may we have pride in our work when the entire basis for this work is immoral?”

A widespread of distrust between the general public of America towards their own government was prevalent during the Seventies.  But that lack of loyalty that more than 50% of the population had wasn’t solely towards the government, as it was also directed to their workplace and employers.  One organization in particular to receive backlash from not only anti-war protesters, but also the very employees working there, was the Honeywell Corporation. Once word got out that Honeywell produced and distributed weapons used in the Vietnam War, weapons that include the very painful and deadly cluster bomb, Honeywell employees expressed their opinions. Nearly 60% of the workers felt that they could not be able to take pride in their jobs and expressed that the company should discontinue making these weapons altogether. Having a large portion of the population go against their own employers on top of having a major lack of trust with the government is a prime example of how the system, and life in general, seemed out of control during the seventies.

“The word was out: get rid of Nixon, but keep the system.”

Zinn’s chapter on the 70s is titled with a question: Were the 70s under control? The turbulent social, political, and economic changes of the 60s carried on into the 70s. The 70s were characterized by antiwar sentiments and distrust in the government due to the immorality of the Vietnam War and the disgrace Nixon’s administration displayed with the Watergate Scandal.

Nixon, as well as the advisers who were involved in Watergate, were not reprimanded harshly at all. Rather, Nixon himself was pardoned by the new president, Gerald Ford. The American government tried to move on from the scandal and hoped to restore faith into the American people. Meanwhile, Ford definitely maintained Nixon’s policy. He continued Nixon’s policy of aid to the Saigon regime. Ford and many government officials not only boasted of victory but they also saw profit to be made in Vietnam. Yet on April 29, 1975, the North Vietnamese moved into Saigon in what is known as the Fall of Saigon. This defeat only deterred faith in the American government.

In an effort to re-introduce the United States’ image to both its’ own country and the world, Secretary Kissinger said, “The U.S. must carry out some act somewhere in the world which shows its determination to continue to be a world power.” So, when the Mayaguez cargo ship was stopped by Cambodians and taken to a nearby port, President Ford sent a message to the Cambodians to release the ship and crew. When there was allegedly no response, Ford sent U.S. planes to bomb Cambodian ships. He also ordered a marine assault on Tang Island. No Americans were hurt, Ford knew this, yet he continued the assault. Ford’s own assault killed 41 Americans. It was considered a “very successful operation” by Secretary of Defense Schlesinger.

I think that Zinn mentions these events because it supports his statement, “What seemed to be happening was that the Establishment- Republicans, Democrats, newspapers, television- was closing ranks behind Ford and Kissinger, and behind the ideas that American authority must be asserted everywhere in the world.” Ever since America was established as a world power, the government in charge sought to retain that power. In a time when confidence in the government was low, the government attempted to divert attention from serious internal affairs by involving themselves in external affairs. Many efforts were made to create the illusion that the system was cleaning itself up, when indeed the system was left unscathed.

Diminishing Patriarchy

Gloria Steinem, Equal Rights for Women—Yes and No (1970)

 

“Women are not more moral than men. We are only uncorrupted by power. But we do not want to imitate men, to join this country as it is, and I think our very participation will change it. Perhaps women elected leaders—and there will be many of them—will not be so likely to dominate black people or yellow or men; anybody who looks different from us.”

Pre-1970s, women were seen as vulnerable, nurturing creatures. It was believed that women were biologically more inclined to desire caretaking, as well as naturally more level-headed than men. Women during the 60s and 70s challenged those beliefs. Gloria Steinem tries to convince a patriarchal society that women should play a role that has been dominated by men since the inception of government. She desires for women to have political power, but strangely, she uses the same preconceived notions about women, thus reinforcing gender stereotypes. She says that women are more moral than men, uncorrupted by power (because women are innocent). She is using these tactics to convince Americans that women should be in power because they will not be as corrupt as men.

Regardless of Steinem’s prominent position in American society as a journalist and social and political activist, she still faced discrimination because of her gender. Since she is a woman, she has faced legal and social discrimination. From being refused to be served in public restaurants, to being turned away from apartment rentals, she has felt the immense pressure to be a stereotypical woman (housewife) and retaliation against her nonconformist ways. The society she lives in isn’t ready to see a self-fulfilled woman like Steinem. They prefer women to be vulnerable, dependent on, and submissive to men, and wear tapes over their mouths. Steinem says no more to this treatment of women as animals. It’s time to take the tape off our mouths.

Where is Our Civil Right?

“We felt that this was our campus, that we were doing nothing wrong, and that they had no right to order us to disperse. If anyone ought to leave, it’s them, not us.”

Tom Grace, The Shooting at Kent State(1970)

              Many Americans had protested the Vietnam War for different reasons by 1970. Especially college students protested strongly because college deferments would be abolished and students would be drafted into military service. Despite the strong protests over the nation, the government sent troops and bombed into Cambodia. It accelerated the protest movement and students of Kent State University held a protest on May 1, 1970. During the protest, four students were killed and nine students were wounded by the National Guard, and the National Guard was exempted from prosecution.

              Students had questioned the way the government slided into war, ignoring people’s intentions. Also, they believed their civil rights to express their opinions should be guaranteed as Tom grace thought, “we were doing nothing wrong, and that they had no right to order us to disperse.” However, the government tried to force people into silence in reality. The shooting at Kent State made people notice that they were actually oppressed by the government and it was not the government of, by and for people.

Excess Of Democracy

“People no longer felt the same obligation to obey those whom they had previously considered superior to themselves in age, rank, status, expertise, character, or talents.”

Samuel Huntington was a part of the group called “The Trilateral Commission” and contributed by writing about problems he has noticed in America, discussing the topic, “The 1960’s witnessed a dramatic upsurge of democratic fervor in America.” Samuel Huntington was a very intelligent man who was a political science professor at Harvard University and a long-time consultant to the White House on the war in Vietnam.

Huntington observed how there was a huge growth of civil participation, however overtime there has been a drastic decrease of government authority, which worried him deeply. Howard Zinn mentions this because during this time, the President needed the public in order to win the election. Meanwhile, the authority of the President was decreasing. Huntington made brave statements about how the position and role of the President wasn’t as strong since many other cooperated and incorporated their ideas, therefore the United States was being governed by anyone. During this time period, there was an extension of democracy. Samuel Huntington even suggested “desirable limits to the extension of political democracy.”
This was very important because throughout the 1960’s, the authority of government continued to drecrease. “The great demands in the sixties for equality had transformed the federal budget.” The fact that the population was spending more and more on foreign affairs as time went by concerned Huntington.

Throughout the 1960s, there was a democratic wave. This effected the power of people who influence others. The authority of the government was at stake. The democratic surge played a role in different forms effecting families, the business world, public and private associations, the governmental bureaucracy, and the military services.

During this time period, Huntington served as a primary force of assistance to bringing back the authority that the government needed to have. He tried  several ways in order to create a more powerful force, and attempted to create change in many ways. He made a brilliant point of how bringing non-partisan soldiers, Republican bankers, and Wall Street lawyers into his force would help. He also got assistance from Eisenhower and Kennedy who also tried teaming up and getting in touch with similar authority figures.The proper solution, according to the Trilateral Commission, was that a tie between the relations of United States, Europe and Japan was necessary.

Feminist Movement

“The law cannot do it for us. We must do it for ourselves. Women in this country must become revolutionaries. We must refuse to accept the old, the traditional roles and stereotypes…. We must replace the old, negative thoughts about our femininity with positive thoughts and positive action….”

Mid-19th century, with the self-awareness of Western women, women’s groups as an independent force in the The stage of history, and set off the first feminist movement for women’s rights. After World War II, more and more women going to work instead of stay in home doing house work, the feminism movement sprout that women didn’t reconcile to be appendant to men and sacrifice to their families any more. People increasingly believe that women in a male-centered society suffer unequal treatment.

“The fight began, many women were saying, with the body, which seemed to be the beginning of the exploitation of women-as sex plaything (weak and incompetent), as pregnant woman (helpless), as middle-aged woman (no longer considered beautiful), as older woman (to be ignored, set aside). ”

The community and even the women themselves think that reproductive rights are women’s rights rather than the rights of men, women are to be masters of their own body, should not be a reproductive tool. Only the implementation of birth control in order to liberate women from having children from heavy activity out. Women’s reproductive function is the reason of male domination. Childbirth and breastfeeding lead women had to rely on the production and protection of men to seek survival. They argued that the emancipation of women, to participate fully in public affairs activities necessary requirement that they have birth control and sexual activity freedom. They believe they have right to decide to be mother and when fertility.

Women Pushing For Change!

“Just what was the problem that has no name? What were the words women used when they tried o express it? Sometimes a woman would say “I feel empty somehow… incomplete.” Or she would say, “I feel as if I don’t exist.” Sometimes… “A tired feeling… I get so angry with the children it scares me… I feel like crying without any reason.”

 By the 1960s, women felt that they were misrepresented in society and had an urge to take charge to have a bigger voice. They were tired of their role as the inferior in the household. This quote is from the book The Feminine Mystique written by the inspirational, Betty Friedman. Betty Friedman was one of the many women that started speaking up and expressing their thoughts and opinions regarding their treatment. Betty spoke about what it was like to be a middle-class housewife, giving an overview of what other women in the same position as her were dealing with. She expressed how every woman felt a sense of yearning and dissatisfaction. They had a gut feeling that something wasn’t right and they all wanted to spend their lives doing something more in order to fill fulfilled and not just be a housewife. Howard Zinn includes Betty Friedman because she was a role model to other women during the time period. Betty influenced them to speak up and realize they deserve better in their life. She made a point that women were living through their husband and children instead of having their own path and journey to take upon. Betty Friedman was a strong woman who knew from the start that change was necessary. Women during the 1960s and 1970s were trapped in a world where they only contributed by being mothers and housewives, feeling isolated and deprived of their freedom. Betty Friedman, being a white middle-class housewife, faced the same struggled that other females were going through and in her book, the “mystique” symbolized the lack of rights and power that woman had, not living their own independent lives. “The only way for a woman, as for a man, to find herself, to know herself as a person, is by creative work of her own.” What Friedman stated in her book was proven to be accurate and true since there was a strike against men shortly after in the summer of 1964. Women were tired of being forced by men to constantly do housework while they they had their freedom. Once Betty Friedman spoke up such as Margaret Benston who also wrote about how women who weren’t working and were housewives were technically like peasants. Women all over the world felt that they needed to stand up for their rights in order to get the change that they want to see.
“I organized this neighborhood organization, two men and six ladies started it. That was a hard pull. A lot of people joined in later. For about five months we had meetings pretty near every night. We learned how to work with other people…. A lot of people were afraid to really do anything. You were afraid to go to the city hall or ask for anything. You didn’t even ask the landlord for anything, you were afraid of him. Then we had meetings and then we weren’t afraid so much anymore…. The way we got this playground: we blocked off the street, wouldn’t let anything come through. We wouldn’t let the trolley bus come through. The whole neighborhood was in it. Took record players and danced; it went on for a week. We didn’t get arrested, they was too many of us. So then the city put up this playground for the kids…”
As difficult of a struggle it was for white women to gain their place in society, it was even more challenging for African American women to find happiness. In order to take a step further in fixing the problems women were facing, services were started in order to unite and become a stronger pact. During the mid 1960s, many African American people living in a neighborhood in Atlanta (up to ten thousand) joined together in order to help each other. They did this by creating a thrift shop, nursery, medical clinic, monthly family suppers, a newspaper, a family, and a counseling service. This quote was from Helen Howard, who was an organizer behind this movement. Helen Howard was a significant person since she supported and put in effort and action in order to push for social change. Howard Zinn included her since she was the main person behind this neighborhood event, organizing it herself. In such quiet protests, women made sure to not be a threat to their locals and used such an intelligent method that provides ways that can actually create a positive effect. Such a method is a good representation showing how women have what it takes to take upon roles in society other than housework. If they were to push for change by rebelling or in an aggressive matter, the outcome would not be one they would hope for since people would assume women would create issues in the society. Helen Howard was seen as an influential and remarkable woman who was strong enough to advocate and stand up for what she believed in, supported by her community. If it wasn’t for her, there would have been no solution to the problems the many woman that looked up to her looking for advice. She was seen as a smart and fearless woman by many.

1960-1970 The Decade of Changes.

Times between 1960’s and 1970’s were very difficult for women. They were deprived of the right to vote, and of the right to freedom. It was difficult for them to decide what really they wanted to do with their lives. The life of women in those days was fixed upfront. When a woman decided to marry a man she already knew that her life would become something totally different the it used to be. She would become a housewife, and her new life would have nothing to do with normal and social life between people as it supposed to be in the society with gender equality. That’s why Howard Zinn quotes a few words from the book The Feminine Mystique written by Betty Friedan. As the women at that time would only “made the beds, shopped for groceries, matched slip-cover material, ate peanut butter sandwiches with her children, chauffeured Cub Scouts and Brownies, lay beside her husband at night” For the majority of men the kind of life that women conducted was something normal and they couldn’t notice any problems that their wives struggled with. They didn’t see that their wives were unhappy
Probably, if writers like Howard Zinn had not written about these times, people of modern world wouldn’t know about these truths and still thought that the gender inequality was something normal. Howard Zinn wants to point out that to be a woman doesn’t mean to be weaker in a political way. Men didn’t know how to talk to their wives because among other things women didn’t have the right to share their feelings because it wasn’t appropriate nor allowed to talk at home “Just what was the problem that has no name? What were the words women used when they tried to express it? Sometimes a woman would say “I feel empty somehow . . . incomplete.” Or she would say, “I feel as if I don’t exist.” Sometimes… “A tired feeling … I get so angry with the children it scares me. … I feel like crying without any reason.” (Betty Friedan) Women as individuals had lack of possibility to speak out about their problems. This fact forced groups of feminists to go out on streets and fix a social order. In 1967 feminist movements discussed the problems which were for women and their dissatisfaction arising from unequal treatment. As Howard Zinn says these kind of movements were possible because of brave and strong women who still tried to care about their freedom “Younger women- Gloria Richardson in Maryland, Annelle Ponder in Mississippi-were not only active, but leaders”(Howard Zinn) Perhaps the leadership and courage that these women had, was an advantage and a window opportunity to speak out. Zinn says about these women as examples of dignity and power to increase awareness in our heads, nowadays, about what was happening back then in 1960’s and 1970’s. In some cases women knew more about politics and surrounded world than men. However, they still couldn’t reach any other and higher job opportunities than only working as a secretary(if they were lucky enough). On the beginning of 1970’s women started to talk about topics that were uncomfortable for men, such as inappropriate treatment of women by police, problems of rapes and procurement. Also, women started to talk more about domestic problems such as “menstruation, masturbation, menopause, abortion, lesbianism.” (Howard Zinn)

1960’s and 1970’s were difficult times for women but even worse times for poor black women in white America. Patricia Robinson wrote a pamphlet called Poor Black Woman in which says “Rebellion by poor black women, the bottom of a class hierarchy heretofore not discussed, places the question of what kind of society will the poor black woman demand and struggle for. Already she demands the right to have birth control, like middle class black and white women. She is aware that it takes two to oppress and that she and other poor people no longer are submitting to oppression, in this case genocide. She allies herself with the have-nots in the wider world and their revolutionary struggles. She had been forced by historical conditions to withdraw the children from male dominance and to educate and support them herself. In this very process, male authority and exploitation are seriously weakened. Further, she realizes that the children will be used as all poor children have been used through history-as poorly paid mercenaries fighting to keep or put an elite group in power. Through these steps .. . she has begun to question aggressive male domination and the class society which enforces it, capitalism.”
Howard Zinn used Patricia Robinson’s words to show how important she is and how much she wrote about difficult poor black women’s lives.  Robinson says that there is nothing worse than being on the bottom of hierarchy; indeed poor black women didn’t have easy lives. There was no pity for them. Even when they wanted equal rights to have birth control it was impossible for them. Also, they had to raise kids by themselves without any other help. Later, those raised children would probably become workers for small wages. This order of life was reprehensible for poor black people that’s why they had to do something with this conditions and suppress rich people’s influence which they used to control poor people’s lives.

Jie Cao’s Extra Credit

Feminist movement organized manner from the beginning of 1966, the landmark event was the establishment of “national women’s movement” organization, Betty Friedan was one of the founders and the organization drafted a constitution. In the last century the sixties and seventies, the United States stirring racial, political and gender conflict among Friedan was one of the loudest voices.
After the feminist movement developed in the universities, the number of female students in the classroom soared; On the political front, the U.S. House of Representatives passed the “Equal Rights Amendment,” Shirley Bridges and Tim became the first U.S. president to participate in the election black women; in culture, books and magazines on women has become hot, a lot of the feminist movement has been included into the dictionary words.
Slogan: Family is not the end