The Five Points of New York

Anbinder’s “Five Points” is a masterpiece at describing the five points of New York during the 1800’s. Although the five points were difficult in that many people were starving for food and thirst, it was a major point in New York history. Anbinder shows the change after immigrants start pouring in, doubling the size of the city. He uses these sources to prove his point:

National Police Gauzette = This is a secondary source because it is not a first hand entry such as a diary. It is reliable, yet skewed towards police views. This is obvious due to its name and its connection to obscenity. Moreover, it was run by a immigrant from Ireland, so it incorporates immigrant views as well.

O’Sullivan Diary Entry = This is a primary resource because it was written hands on by a person experiencing what she is writing about. The information could be reliable, but it would be important to disclude all information pertaining to opinion.

Times = This is a primary source because it states the prices of repairs and items during the time period mentioned. Furthermore, it is reliable because there is no bias involved and is merely information.

This entry was posted in February 28 Assignment and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

Comments are closed.