-
Recent Posts
Recent Comments
Archives
Categories
Meta
Author Archives: kinga.chutkowska
Posts: 11 (archived below)
Comments: 0
Baldesar Castiglione
The paragraph “Woman Exemplify Grace” from The Book of the Courtier by Baldesar Castiglione describes women “inordinate desire to be beautiful.” (C, 244) The author gives many examples of how women want to improve their beauty such as, they use make up. However, they seem not to realize that men know different tricks used by women. Also, many activities are not liked by males. For example, the author is very sarcastic while talking about make up. “[S]he seems to have put a mask on her face and dares not laugh so as not to cause it to crack, and never changes color except in the morning when she dresses; and, then, for the rest of the entire day remains motionless like a wooden statue and shows herself only by torchlight, like wily merchants who display their cloth in a dark place.” (C, 244)
The New York Times article “Market Watch/Lashfully” by Chelsea Zalopany is about women’ desire to improve their physical appearance. The author describes that many women decide to take a special care about their eye lashes. Ladies used mascaras to make their eye lashes longer and sexier. However, new technology is discovered. Chelsea explains “[t]he process is surprisingly (and refreshingly) painless — a lash artist assesses one’s existing lash shape and designs a custom style based on multiple lengths, curvatures and widths. Each lash is applied individually (typically 70 to 100 are added per eye) and first-time visitors should expect the process to take one to two hours. The cost runs from $250 to $275.”
In both readings women use different tricks to improve their beauty, no matter what is the price they have to pay (in first reading the price is being an object of farce, in second reading the price is a huge part of income spend on beauty supplies).
Posted in Uncategorized
Comments Off on Baldesar Castiglione
The Thousand and One Night is a collection of classic Islamic literature. In the beginning of that collection, the king, Shahrayar, is informed that his wife cheats on him. He gets very angry and decides to kill both lovers. After this situation the king is very upset. He sees that women are dishonest and it leads him to take very brutal and unethical action: he gets married with a young girl from his kingdom, he spends night with her, and finally he kills a bride when the sun rises. He repeats this ritual every day and it is his way to be sure that his wife will always be loyal and never cheats on him, as happened before.
Shahrazad is a daughter of the vizier who serves in the kingdom. Vizier is a person who has to kill every bride who spends night with the king. When Shahrazad tells her father that she wants to get married with a king, vizier tries to influence and change her mind. However, he is unable to do so. Finally, Shahrazad and Shahrayar get married. Before the sun rises Shahrazad asks about the permission to say goodbye to her lovely sister. When Dunyazad comes to the king’s bedroom she asks about one thing; she wants Shahrazad to tell her the last story before she will die. Both, the king and Dunyazad listen to the tale very carefully with a passion and great interest. So, when the sun rises, Shahrazad stops her stories. She stops in the most interesting point, so king wants to hear the rest of the story and he doesn’t kill his wife. Shahrazad smartly continues her action: she tells a story every night and she keeps the most interesting part to the moment of sunrise. Then king wants to hear the end of the story and doesn’t kill her. Shahrazad tells thousand and one stories. During that time she gives her husband three children; she gains Shahrayar’s love and changes him from tyrant to a good king who cares about his kingdom and people leaving in there.
The New York Times article “Diana’s Ring Seals Prince William’s Marriage Plans” by Sarah Lyall is about Prince William who plans to get married soon. He proposes to his girlfriend, Kate Middleton, and he is accepted. The couple will marriage in spring or summer 2011.
There are few similarities between Shahrazad and Kate Middleton. First of all, both are very well educated. Shahrazad “had read the books of literature, philosophy, and medicine. She knew poetry by heart, had studied historical reports, and was acquainted with the sayings of men and the maxims of sages and kings. She was intelligent, knowledgeable, wise, and refined. She had read and learned.” (B, 414) Similarly, Kate Middleton is intelligent and well educated woman. She met Prince “at the University of St. Andrews in Scotland.” In addition, the article stays that if she becomes a queen “she would be the first queen in British history to have a college degree, or indeed, to have any college education at all.”
Also, both are willing to get married with a king. Shahrazad says to her father “I would like you to marry me to King Shahrayar.” (B, 414) She knows that her father disagrees with her wish and she black mails him in order to get his acceptance. Similarly, Kate Middleton wants to get married with a Prince. She stays in relationship with him for few years and waits for his proposal. As the article says she was called by tabloids as “Waity Katie” which reference to her waiting behavior.
In addition, both are from rich families, however; they are not princesses. Shahrazad is a daughter of vizier who serves in court. Her father has enough money to support himself and his two daughters. In addition, he pays for their education. She comes from an aristocratic family; however, she is not a princess. Similarly, Kate Middleton comes from rich family “her father is a former British Airways officer and her mother a former flight attendant; together, they run a successful mail-order business that sells paraphernalia for children’s parties,” but she is not a princess.
Finally, both have an understanding of difficulties which comes with their decisions to get married with a king. Shahrazad knows that “[i]t become King Shahrayar’s custom to take every night the daughter of a merchant or a commoner, spend the nigh with her, then have her put to death next morning” (B, 414). Even if she has a plan how to change the king’s behavior, she is not sure if it will work. Similarly, Kate Middleton knows a story of Prince’s mother, Lady Diana “whose short life ended when she was killed after a car accident in Paris in 1997.”
Posted in The Thousand and One Nights
Comments Off on
Throne of Blood
The New York Times article “Sprawling Cinema, Tamed to a Stage” by Charles Isherwood is a theatre review of a play “Throne of Blood.” The author of the article dislikes the play and critiques both the director and the actors performing on the stage. He says “…a new production from the Next Wave Festival at the Brooklyn Academy of Music, would be as boring to look at as it is to listen to.” He also comperes the play with the film “Throne of Blood” made by Japanese move maker Akira Kurosawa. He states that even if the play is boring and static, the movie has a specific “atmospheric effect.” Also, it is “beautifully designed” and “offer[s] an eyeful of visual poetry.” I partially agree with Charles Isherwood. The play is very static and motionless which makes viewers a little bit bored. Also, the accessories used for decoration are very limited. However, actors’ costumes are chosen with good taste and harmony. The minimalism of action and accessories; however, keeps audiences focused on the play. In addition, the play takes viewers to different world; world full of magic creatures such as ghosts, world full of intrigues such as killing the king, world full of unfamiliar creatures such as samurais. It gives the audiences great opportunity to experience magical world and it is a good way of entertainment. And the most important, it forces people to think and decide if they believe that they are the masters of their own lives or if they are just powerless creatures directed by destiny.
Posted in Asian Literature
1 Comment
Asian Literature
Lesson for Women written by Ban Zhao is a set of rules given by a mother to her daughters and all the female family members. This text describes the role and duties of women in China around c. 100. The author divides the work into seven sections including: Humility, Husband and Wife, Respect and Caution, Womanly Qualifications, Wholehearted Devotion, Implicit Obedience, and Harmony with Younger Brothers-and Sisters-in-law.
First of all, all the women should learn how to be humble. They supposed to value family’s needs more than their own. They “retire late to bed, but rise early to duties” (B, 28). Even if they work really hard to clean, cook, serve food, and take care about children, they shouldn’t feel proud about themselves and tell anybody about their hard work. Women gain excellent reputations only if they stay humble, do all work they are expected to do and never argue with their relatives.
Also, the husband takes control over his wife. She is not only the housekeeper and babysitter but also a sex servant at home. Only one “thing” a man possess, no matter of his social status, is his wife and her services. So she can’t refuse to do her marriage duties. The control man takes over her is a sign of authority and lack of it can be seen as a lost of power for a man. “…wives must be controlled and that the husband’s roles of conduct manifesting his authority must be established” (B, 28).
In addition, since man and woman have different characters, their roles are also different. A man is valued by his strength while a woman is valued mostly by her beauty and gentleness. Respect between the wife and husband is mandatory in order to create a good couple. Even if “[t]he correct relationship between husband and wife is based upon harmony and intimacy, and conjugal love is grounded in proper union” husband is permitted to beat his wife. (B, 29)
Additionally, there are many qualifications which describe proper behavior of all women. First, woman words don’t need to be clear and clever. She just needs to choose her words with a special attention and care and avoid improper languages. Second, she needs to keep her head and body clean and fresh. Her clothes should be washed with special care and always be in good condition. Third, wife supposes to cook and serve not only for family but also all guests who visit the house. Last, there is an image of a woman who can’t survive without a relationship with a man.
Moreover, even if a husband can remarry, there is no permission for a wife to do so. Woman is strongly depended on her husband “[t]o obtain the love of one man is the crown of a woman’s life; to lose the love of one man is to miss the aim in woman’s life” (B, 30). Also, ladies can’t flirt with men or use other methods to be close to them. They can’t even make groups with other ladies and discuss different aspect or laugh as well.
Last but not least, wife has to stay in good relationship with her husband’s family. If the mother-in-law says something the wife can’t criticize her and can’t do anything against her. Even if the directions are wrong, wife can’t ignore them. Also, she has to keep good relationship with her brothers-in-law and sisters-in-law. It can be extremely helpful in order to stay in good mental condition and make life at home less complicated and sustainable. “[T]he praise and the blame of a woman alike depends upon younger brother-and sister-in law (B, 31).” In some cases family-in-law can banish the wife which cause many trouble in her life.
Similarly, the article “For Afghan Wives, a Desperate, Fiery Way Out” by Alissa J. Rubin is about marginalization of the woman’s role in the society. As the author mentioned, arranged marriages are very popular in Afghanistan. Girls get married mostly in their childhood or as teenagers. Their main duties are to cook, clean, serve, take care about the children and husband’s family members. Very often, wives are abused by their husbands or husband’s family. “Violence in the lives of Afghanistan’s women comes from everywhere: from her father or brother, from her husband, from her father-in-law, from her mother-in-law and sister-in-law.” It leads to depression of the woman and in extremely cases can also lead to suicide by placing themselves into a fire.
Posted in Asian Literature
1 Comment
Midterm questions
Questions:
- Compare and contrast the role of the God/gods in Genesis, the Epic of Gilgamesh and the Odyssey.
- Is Odysseus a good leader?
- Analyze and give an example of the situation when a protagonist(s) from Genesis is (are) between Scylla and Charybdis.
Posted in The Odyssey
Comments Off on Midterm questions
Blog#6
One of the best know antique piece of writing is Odyssey by Homer. It is a story about a hero, Odysseus, who fights in Troy. When he is coming back home he blinds Poseidon’s son what causes many problems in his life and expend his journey. The god of oceans gets very angry and tries to do everything to make Odysseus way to be very difficult and as long as possible. During the journey Odysseus has to make many difficult decisions such as how to protect himself and his people. Once he faces extremely complicated situation. He has to decide if he wants to pick a way where Scylla, monster living in the rocks, will kill six of his people or if he picks another way and everybody in the cruse will die because of other monster Charybdis.
“Charybdis gulps the dark water down. Three times a day she vomits it up, three times she gulps it down, that terror! Don’t be there when the whirlpool swallows down-not even the earthquake god could save you from disaster. No, hug Scylla’s crag-sail on past her-top speed! Better by far to lose six men and keep your ship than lose your entire crew.” (A 402)
Finally, Odysseus scarifies six of his friends and leads his cruse to meet Scylla. Few of his people die however most of them survive. The idiom “between Scylla and Charybdis” is used in modern world to describe the situation where avoidance of one danger exposes one to another danger or making any possible choices lead to seriously consequences.
The New York Times article “No Clear Path for China After Nobel Choice” by Didi Kirsten Tatlow is about Chinese dissident Liu Xiaobo who won Nobel Prize. He is one of the revolutionists who fight for human rights in communistic China. Because of his action against the government he went to jail for 11 years (and he is still in jail now). The commission which decides who is allegeable for Nobel Prize had to face very difficult problem. Liu Xiaobo is called as criminal by Chinese communists; however, in other countries he is seeing as super hero who fights for human rights. Many people believe that if he lives in China he has to be following Chinese law. They argue “[e]ach country has its own laws, its own rules and its own profit, no matter what. For a person who is a criminal under Chinese law to win the Nobel Peace Prize, well, that’s ironic.” Others claim that no matter what the law says the human rights are basic rights and can’t be omitted. They response that “everyone knows there are problems in China related to lack of human rights and democracy” and use this metaphor: “even if you know your mother is ugly, you’re still unhappy when you hear others saying it. What you want to do is to protect and change her, not listen to others criticize her” to describe the situation in China. In addition, China is one of the biggest countries which trades oversee. Taking any action against the government can cause disagreement and loses in global market. That’s why Noble Prize commission was between Scylla and Charibdys. They could give a Nobel Prize to Liu and break up good relationship with China or against their believes give it to one of the other candidates and keep good relationship with that country.
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/15/world/asia/15iht-letter.html?ref=liu_xiaobo
Posted in The Odyssey
1 Comment
Blog#5
The Odyssey by Homer is a story about a soldier, Odysseus, who has to live his family before the Troy war in which he fights. Unfortunately, he is coming back to Ithaca is 20 years. During this time his son, Telemachus, is growing up and becomes an adult man. His wife, Penelope, is adored by many suitors who want to marry her. However, she is not interested in any of them because she still loves Odysseus and still believes he will be back home. As Telemachus says “[h]e [Odysseus] fathered me, he left me behind at home, and from me he got no joy. So now our house is plagued by swarms of enemies.” (A 451) Even if many men occupy her house and waste her wealth she can’t get rid of them because of hospitality law which is very important in Ithaca. Also, she asks gods to take care about her husband and protect him during his journey. Finally, with Athena’s help Odysseus comes back home and enjoy reunion with his family. “…the royal couple, once they’d reveled in all the longed-for joys of love, reveled in each other’s stories…” (A 539)
The New York Times article “Trapped 68 Days, First Chilean Miners Taste Freedom” by Alexei Barrionuevo and Simon Romero is about miners trapped underground for 68 days. During first 17 days they didn’t have contact with the rest of the world. After that they were able to communicate with others. By using advanced technology they kept in touch with their families and friends. It was extremely important to give them hope to be refused and keep them in good mental condition. After that time the small capsule was used to refuse all miners one by one. When the capsule opened they could enjoy reunion with their relatives who strongly believed in happy end of that horrible accident. One of the fathers who waited for his so to be refused said full of happiness “My boy is finally safe. My boy is finally safe.” Also, families pray to God to help all miners to be rescued. They said “We hope that with the help of God this epic will end in a happy way.” All miners were able to enjoy reunion with their families.
http://www.nytimes.com/2010/10/13/world/americas/13chile.html?scp=1&sq=68%20days&st=cse
Posted in The Odyssey
Comments Off on Blog#5
The Book of Job
The Book of Job is one of the sections from a Bible’ Old Testament. Job is a rich and successful man “greatest of all people of the east,” who has everything that can make someone happy and thankful (A 126). He owns “seven thousand sheep, three thousand camels, five hundred yoke of oxen and five hundred she-asses” (A 126). Also, he has a big family with “seven sons and three daughters” (A 126). He fully trusts God and never does anything against his rules. One day Satan argues with God about Job’s honesty. In addition, he convinces God to give Job some test to prove his point. Then, in one night Job loses his goods and children. However, he still believes in God and his honesty. Even though he becomes seriously sick, his faith stays as strong as before. Because of all experiences, Job curses the day when he was born “Job opened his mouth and cursed the day of his birth;” however, he doesn’t curse God (A 126). His wife and friends are not powerful enough to change his belief in God. Finally, after many days of suffering God blesses him again and returns all goods and previously lost family members. God “gave Job twice as much as he had before” (A, 139). Also, because of Job’s deep faith God doesn’t punish his friends who stop trusting him. In addition, God gives them a lesson that he is the only one authority who has absolute power and has the right to create things in his own will. No one should seek for a reason about the creation of the world the way it is. In addition, no one should rise against him.
The article “Recalling a Simple Life in Brooklyn” by Dale Russakoff is about an old lady Jessie Singer Sylvester who died about 20 years ago. One of her family member finds a diary where she describes her daily activities. The diary is out of excitements and emotions but it seems to be very interesting because all days are described pretty well. As her family member said “It was this extremely spare, unemotional, very functional, daily record of her life, but I was mesmerized and I saw a real poetry in it. It was precious to me to know that even after all the losses; she continued to find her life meaningful.” Finally, the diary becomes the source of making a movie about ordinary life of the old lady. The film won few awards and become relish word widely.
As I was reading both pieces of writing I found few similarities. Firstly, both literary works are about huge loss. Job loses his seven sons and three daughters. In addition, he loses his all goods including domestic animals. Besides, he suffers from painful sickness. Satan “afflicted Job with loath-some sores from the sole of his foot to the crown of his head” (A 127). Similarly, Ms. Sylvester experienced many losses. She was “absorbing one loss after the next — her job of 59 years, her beloved sister, her friends, her sense of security, her sharp mind.”
Secondly, Job and Ms.Sylvester both accept their fortunes silently. Job doesn’t see his bad luck as a punishment. He knows that God gives everything and he can take it away whenever he wants. That’s why even if he curses the day he was born, he never curses to God. Job is a man who loses many things in his life and suffers as a result of it. As a mortal creature he accepts his destiny without a question. Similarly, Ms. Sylvester is a person who doesn’t blame anybody for her loses. She accepts it as a part of her life and a normal event in human life. “It really drives home the point that life is not made up of great big events. It’s an accumulation of little things that happen every day that can make or break you.”
Finally, Job and Ms. Sylvester both receive a great gift after their experiences. God decides to return everything what he took away from Job “…and he had fourteen thousand sheep, six thousand camels, a thousand yoke of oxen, and a thousand she-asses” (A 139-140). Therefore, he becomes a rich man again. His family is completed with “…seven sons and three daughters” (A 140). Moreover, his animals are back in the fields. Also, “Ms. Sylvester, 22 years after her death, is experiencing a rebirth.” In fact, a movie named “Beautiful Hills of Brooklyn” is made from the story taken from her diary.
Posted in Book of Job
Comments Off on The Book of Job
Comparison: Gilgamesh and Genesis
The Epic of Gilgamesh is one of the oldest pieces of writing which was discovered by people, so far. It was written in around 1000B.C.E in the Near East region in ancient Mesopotamia. Similarly, Genesis is one of the best books known worldwide which was written in around 400 B.C.E. In addition, it came from the region of Mesopotamia.
The Epic of Gilgamesh presents the polytheistic world where gods and goddesses play a big role. Even if they hold great power and are able to influence people’s actions, sometimes they are weak and imperfect. Also, mortal people and immortal gods have many things in common. They both experience positive and negative feelings such as love, happiness, and anger. For example, when Gilgamesh refuses to marry goodness Ishtar “in a fury she went up to the heavens, going to Anu, her father, and crying, going to Antum, her mother, and weeping” (A 77). Correspondingly, Genesis also describes the world where God plays a big role. However, he is the only monotheistic God and other gods don’t exist. In addition, he is the God who holds all the power; thus, everything depends on his will. For example, he says “Let there be light. And there was light” (A 29). Moreover, he doesn’t have many things in common with mortal people whom he created.
Both readings mention the flood; however, the reason of it is different. In the Epic of Gilgamesh people multiply very fast and earth become too noisy. Gods can’t stand that situation and send flood to destroy human beings. Gods choose a mortal human being, Utnapishtim, to create a ship and collect the pairs of all animals existing in the world. He says “I had all my kith and kin go up into the boat, all the beasts, and animals of the field” (A 92). In addition, gods let him to protect his family and craftsmen “and the craftsmen I had go up” who have a great amount of knowledge which can be reused later on (A 92). On the other hand, Genesis talks about flood from different perspective. It is a punishment for people who want to be equal to God. “And the Lord saw that the evil of the human creature was great on the earth and that every scheme of his heart’s devising was only perpetually evil. And Lord regretted having made the human on earth” (A 34). As a result, he lets Noah to build an arc and collect the pairs of all animals existing in the world. God says to Noah “and you shall enter the ark, you and your sons and your wife and the wives of your sons, with you. And from all that lives, from all flesh, two of each thing you shall bring to the ark to keep alive with you, male and female they shall be” (A 34). Also, Noah family is one who survives and populates the earth.
Posted in Genesis - Gilgamesh
2 Comments
Gilgamesh#2
I found connections between the Epic of Gilgamesh and The New York Times article “The Best Two Women Could Do” written by Ariel Kaminer. The article is about a lesbian couple who faces many difficulties. However, they are highly motivated to solve problems together.
Both pieces of writings project very intimate relationships between two people. The Epic of Gilgamesh describes the friendship between Gilgamesh and Enkidu. They are introduced to each other in a fight; thus, it creates an extremely high connection between them. Gilgamesh’s mother says something interesting about Enkidu (while she is translating a dream) when she asserts that “the axe that you saw is a man, whom you love and embrace as a wife, but whom I have made compete with you” (A 65). Also, Gilgamesh calls Enkidu a “friend and advisor” with a great respects (A 65). Similarly, “The Best Two Women Could Do” is about two ladies, Ms. Bacolas and Ms. Glazer, who are “introduced by a mutual friend outside a bar.” Then, they fall in love and spend every weekend together. In fact, they went to parties, they went dancing, and “in the mornings, Ms. Bacolas cooked them amazing breakfasts: scrambled eggs with truffle oil, feta and tomatoes on millet toast. After too many years in heavy, doomed relationships, they could not get over how easy it all was” which represents their strong relationship.
In both cases, they are looking to improve their lives which require them to travel. Gilgamesh and Enkidu travel to Cedar Forest to kill Humbaba and become famous for many generations. They know that death takes away bodies but immortality is to be memorable for others. In addition, it is necessary to “establish fame” (A 73). However, they also use their trips as a source of getting cedar wood which is expensive and desired material used for building walls. Similarly, Ms. Bacolas and Ms. Glazer have to travel outside of New York City to make their marriage dream come true. Also, marriage gave them an opportunity to “ protect themselves and their joint property, as they wanted to give Ms. Bacolas the right to make medical decisions on Ms. Glazer’s behalf,” which gave them comfort of sharing and improvement in their lives.
Last but not least, in both examples health condition of one partner seriously affects the other. For instance, Gilgamesh sees Enkidu slowly losing energy as “Enkidu lies down [the] first day, [the second] second day,…[until] Enkidu’s illness grew ever worse” and when he dies “Enkidu’s eyes do not move, as [Gilgamesh] touched his heart , but it beat no longer” and Gilgamesh doesn’t want to burn Enkidu’s body (A 82-83). Moreover, he becomes very upset and behaves in a wild manner. Therefore, he feels afraid of death and wants to find a way to becomes immortal. Similarly, Ms. Bacolas and Ms. Glazer are affected by unexpected cancer. “Ms. Glazer learned she had breast cancer. A double mastectomy followed, then five more operations, along with radiation and chemotherapy.” They face serious illness which can lead to death and separation of their love. So, they don’t postpone important decisions anymore. They also have great opportunity to see the strength of their feelings and fight against the cancer together.
Posted in Gilgamesh
Comments Off on Gilgamesh#2