Name: Ibrahim Kidwai
Date: 8/17/23
English 2150
Annotated Bibliography
Abbas, H. (2007). Islamic political radicalism in Pakistan. The Washington Quarterly, 30(3), 7-19.
1. Examines the growth of Islamic extremism in Pakistan and its effects on the country’s politics, society, and relations with the West.
2. Analyzes the origins and ideology of Pakistani militant groups, their links to al-Qaeda, reasons for their swelling popularity, and repercussions of an Islamist takeover on Pakistani stability.
3. Written for policymakers, journalists, and scholars studying South Asian politics and Islamic movements.
4. Directly relevant to understanding radical Islamist trends in the contemporary Muslim world.
5. Provides nuanced assessment situating extremism within Pakistan’s complex internal dynamics.
6. Relies heavily on the author’s expertise but is overall well-sourced and balanced.
Afsaruddin, A. (2013). What sharia law means: Five questions answered. The Conversation. https://theconversation.com/what-sharia-law-means-five-questions-answered-79325
1. Aims to explain the meaning and role of Shariah law in Islam to a general audience.
2. Provides overview of origins, sources, interpretations, legal rulings, and modern debates surrounding Shariah.
3. Accessible introduction geared towards non-specialist Western readers.
4. Succinctly summarizes key aspects of Shariah relevant to essay topic.
5. Answers common questions and clarifies misunderstandings about nature of Islamic law.
6. As short primer, lacks nuance but serves as solid starting reference on the subject.
Ahmed, S. (2012). What is Islam? The importance of being Islamic. Princeton University Press.
1. Book examines the existential question of what it means to be Muslim in the contemporary world.
2. Combining theology and anthropology, analyzes core Islamic beliefs on God, prophecy, and religious practice as well as debates on Islamic reform and identity.
3. Aimed at general readership interested in religion and politics.
4. Provides comprehensive scholarly overview of theological foundations of Islam.
5. Unique in bridging traditional Islamic sources and modern critical theory.
6. Well-researched overall, but shaped by author’s reformist perspective.
Ernst, C. W. (2004). Eternal garden: Mysticism, history, and politics at a South Asian Sufi center. Oxford University Press.
1. Ethnographic study of mystical Islam at the shrine of Mu’in al-Din Chishti in India.
2. Examines the shrine’s history, patronage, rituals, interfaith connections, and political controversies.
3. Academic monograph written for Islamic studies specialists.
4. Highlights Sufism’s cultural influence in South Asia and syncretism with Hinduism.
5. Combines extensive fieldwork with analysis of primary Persian texts.
6. Balanced account situating the shrine in its unique context.
Esposito, J.L. (2019). Islam: The straight path. Oxford University Press.
1. Standard textbook overview of Islam for undergraduate education.
2. Traces Islam’s origins and development, beliefs, rituals, law, and cultural diversity across sects and regions.
3. Comprehensive survey geared for students seeking broad introduction.
4. Succinctly summarizes main tenets and practices of Islam.
5. Integrates theological and historical perspectives.
6. Accessible and mostly neutral, but skips some complex controversies.
Ghaly, M. (2012). Biotechnology and the Islamic ruling on changing human genes. Zygon, 47(2), 434-450.
1. Discusses debates on ethics of genetic engineering within Islamic bioethical scholarship.
2. Analyzes arguments from primary Arabic juridical texts to derive Islamic principles on altering human genes.
3. Academic article written for specialized bioethics and Islam readership.
4. Highlights how Islamic bioethics approaches novel technologies based on interpreting scripture.
5. Traces nuances across historical and modern Islamic legal rulings.
6. Well-researched analysis limited to Sunni perspectives on the issue.
Gottschalk, P., & Greenberg, G. (2008). Islamophobia: Making Muslims the enemy. Rowman & Littlefield Publishers.
1. Scholarly examination of anti-Muslim prejudice and propaganda in the West.
2. Traces historical roots and contemporary surge in negative stereotypes fueling discrimination against Muslims.
3. Written to inform policymakers and general readers about this pressing social issue.
4. Central to understanding how geo-politics and media shape Islam’s image.
5. Covers wide range of material from films to legal cases demonstrating Islamophobia.
6. Limited focus on the American context.
Kramer, M. (2003). Coming to terms: Fundamentalists or Islamists? Middle East Quarterly, 10(2), 65-77.
1. Article debating the terminology used to describe political Islamic movements.
2. Argues against the term “fundamentalist” and for greater usage of “Islamist” on theoretical and practical grounds.
3. Aimed at scholars and policy analysts working in the Middle East.
4. Relevant to essay’s discussion of Islamic revivalist movements and debates on interpreting Islam.
5. Traces the history of both terms and problems in their common employment.
6. Well-argued but largely theoretical distinctions lacking empirical grounding.
Lipka, M. & Hackett, C. (2017). Why Muslims are the world’s fastest-growing religious group. Pew Research Center. https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/04/06/why-muslims-are-the-worlds-fastest-growing-religious-group/
1. Statistics-based article reporting on Muslim population growth for general readership.
2. Summarizes demographic data on Muslim birth rates, lifespan, age distribution and conversion rates accounting for Islam’s spread.
3. Aimed at non-specialist audience interested in religious trends.
4. Quantifies key facts about Islam’s global followers relevant to essay topic.
5. Draws on Pew Research Center’s extensive data resources.
6. Limited explanatory analysis on implications of Muslim population growth.
Lipman, J.N. (1997). Familiar strangers: A history of Muslims in Northwest China. University of Washington Press.
1. Scholarly examination of Muslim communities in China’s Xinjiang region from 1800 to 1949.
2. Focuses on interplay between Chinese Muslim and Han ethnic groups, blending of customs, and effects of Muslim rebellions.
3. Academic monograph for specialists in Chinese ethnic studies.
4. Relevant to essay’s discussion of cultural diversity within Islam.
5. Synthesizes Chinese and Western sources to reconstruct overlooked history.
6. Emphasizes state-ethnic minority power relations over analysis of religious practices.
Mernissi, F. (1991). The veil and the male elite: A feminist interpretation of Islam. Perseus.
1. Pioneering feminist critique of patriarchal structures and gender ideology in Islam.
2. Argues misogynist tendencies stem from misinterpretations of Islamic texts by male elites. Calls for egalitarian re-reading of the early tradition.
3. Groundbreaking work aimed at general Muslim and feminist readerships.
4. Highly relevant to the essay’s examination of women’s issues in contemporary Islam.
5. Combines theological arguments with historical analysis in an accessible style.
6. Focuses exclusively on textual sources, lacking fieldwork exploring lived realities.
Nasr, S.H. (2015). Islam: Religion, history, and civilization. HarperOne.
1. Authoritative comprehensive textbook on all dimensions of Islamic tradition.
2. Traces doctrinal history from the Quran to modern movements, philosophy, law, rituals, art, and cultural embodiments across Muslim world.
3. Reference work geared for students seeking in-depth understanding.
4. Essential source summarizing Islam’s origins, diversity, and evolution.
5. Integrates extensive scholarship from a traditional Islamic viewpoint.
6. Emphasizes theological narrative over critical historical analysis.
Ousmane, O.M. (2012). Beyond Timbuktu: An intellectual history of Muslim West Africa. Harvard University Press.
1. Surveys key intellectual figures and written traditions that shaped West African Muslim scholarship and society.
2. Spans the iconic Timbuktu madrassas to Pan-African philosophy, emphasizing transmission of knowledge.
3. Academic work for scholars of African and Islamic history.
4. Highlights cultural diversity within Islam’s intellectual heritage.
5. Draws from Arabic primary sources largely unknown in the West.
6. Could provide more contextualization in broader social developments.
Pew Research Center. (2007). Muslim Americans: Middle class and mostly mainstream. https://www.pewresearch.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/7/legacy-pdf/muslim-americans.pdf
1. Data-based study profiling the attitudes and demographics of Muslim Americans.
2. Reports on views on politics, social issues, terrorism, identity, and experiences of discrimination.
3. Survey report aimed at journalists, policymakers, and the general public.
4. Valuable statistics illustrating Muslim integration patterns in the West.
5. Part of Pew’s rigorous survey research on religious groups.
6. Provides a snapshot at one point in time; attitudes evolve over generations.
Ramadan, T. (1999). To be a European Muslim. Islamic Foundation.
1. Philosophical work reflecting on challenges of Islamic identity for Western Muslims.
2. Calls for articulating an authentically European Islam true to both sides of identity.
3. Written for educated Muslim readership navigating Western secular environments.
4. Explores questions of belonging, ritual, law, and politics surrounding Muslim minorities.
5. Blends intellectual history and cultural analysis unique among Muslim reformist thinkers.
6. Focuses on British context with less insight on continental European experiences.
Shah, I. (2015). The blood print of terror: Trauma, violence, and politics in the Indian novel. Comparative Studies of South Asia, Africa and the Middle East, 35(3), 544-562.
1. Scholarly literary analysis of depictions of communal violence in Indian fiction.
2. Examines metaphors, imagery, and symbolism writers use to convey trauma of ethno-religious conflict.
3. Academic article aimed at researchers of postcolonial and South Asian literature.
4. Provides insight into cultural impacts of communal tensions involving Muslims in India.
5. Makes sophisticated intertextual arguments linking tropes across select novels.
6. Focuses on textual analysis without much contextual grounding of the works.