By Jonathan Sperling
The auditorium at the University of Maine at Farmington filled quickly with students and townspeople one evening in April to hear from the Democratic candidates hoping to unseat Bruce Poliquin, the elusive incumbent Republican Congressman who has occupied the seat for two terms.
The forum held by the university’s College Democrats club was for Democratic candidates only, Poliquin’s absence has become something of a theme in this election campaign. In May 2017, Poliquin was so eager to avoid answering a reporter’s question about his position on health care that he ducked into the nearest women’s restroom–a moment that made national news.
“I think Poliquin’s presence hasn’t been felt in the 2nd Congressional District and that’s why we’re here—he does not show up for his constituents at all, ” said Astra Pierson, 21, president of the College Democrats, who argues that Poliquin is beholden to his big-money contributors, not to voters.
Now Democratic candidates are hoping that Poliquin’s absence from the district gives them a chance to defeat him in November, despite the Republican’s sizable campaign war chest and incumbent status.

Farmington lies in the southern section of the 2nd District, a 27,000-square-mile area that is 80 percent of Maine. The district is characterized by an aging voter base, widespread economic decline and a shrinking population, with many young people moving south, especially to the Portland area, in recent years. Voter engagement and registration in the state is high, with 996,853 Mainers — nearly 75 percent of the state’s entire population — registered to vote just before the 2016 Presidential election, the highest in the state’s history, according to The Portland Press Herald. The number of registered Democrats jumped from 309,100 to 324,820 and the number of registered Republicans rose from 263,392 to 267, 586.
With the primary election scheduled on June 12, the Farmington Democratic forum highlighted the issues that are of keenest interest to local voters: gun control, Medicare for all, job creation and environmental protection.
While health care and gun ownership are national issues, they have special resonance in Maine, where older voters helped carry the Medicaid expansion and almost everyone likes to hunt. “People vote with local politics in mind, especially because in the 2nd District, a lot of people are living below the poverty line and a lot of people are really only thinking about the thing in front of them…I’m not sure that people have the means or privilege even to spend a lot of time thinking about politics,” said Pierson of the college democratic club.
RELATED COVERAGE: Voters of the 2nd District on issues and the race
While the number of registered Democrats has been on the rise, Maine voters have not elected only Democrats in recent years. President Donald Trump swept the 2nd District in 2016—the first time the 2nd District had voted differently than the 1st District in a presidential election in nearly half a century—and two years earlier Republican Gov. Paul LePage won re-election and Republican Senator Susan Collins was re-elected to a third term.
“It’s a district that will elect Democratic state representatives and Republican senators; this is what you would describe as a purple state, rather than red or blue,” said State Representative and Congressional candidate Jared Golden at the forum. “The conventional wisdom is that these voters all just flipped. The same electorate that went for Trump in this district also voted at the ballot box to increase our minimum wage from $7.50 an hour to $12 an hour by 2020. In November, around 52 percent of the population voted to expand Medicaid. Those are two Democratic policies, so I would make an argument that it’s not that they are moving right or running away from the Democratic Party. They just have, at times, lost faith that the party is representing their needs.”
Golden is the most politically experienced of the three candidates remaining in the race in the weeks before the June primary, and the odds-on favorite. He won a seat in the Maine House of Representatives in 2014 and re-election in 2016. Both times, Golden trounced Republican opponents; in 2016, he handily defeated Jeffery Padham by garnering 2,420 votes to Padham’s 962. As a state representative, Golden brings something to the table that his three Democratic opponents cannot: a documented voting record in support of unions, clean energy and fair wages, among other progressive ideals. Golden is also a combat veteran and former Marine; he enlisted following the September 11 attacks, a fact that will surely increase his favor among conservative, pro-veteran voters.
The most colorful of the Democratic candidates is Lucas St. Clair, a conservationist and outdoorsman whose supporters, toting St. Clair banners and pamphlets, lined the path to the auditorium where the forum was held. St. Clair is quick to note that he is a gun owner and hunter, although he says he supports “common-sense” gun measures. St. Clair’s mother is Roxanne Quimby — a co-founder of Burt’s Bees, the personal-care products company — who bought up large swaths of land around Baxter State Park and donated it to the federal government for use as a National Park; she enraged locals by banning hunting and snowmobiling on the land. St. Clair’s support comes from voters who appreciated his deft handling of his mother’s gift; St. Clair arranged for the land to be established as a much-less-restrictive national monument and reopened the land for recreation. The monument has been an economic boon to the area since it opened in August 2016.

“It’s hard to go down to Washington and retain your integrity and commitment to your constituents without falling into other agendas,” said Marsha Donahue, a lifelong Independent who says she registered as a Democrat in order to vote for St. Clair in the Democratic Party Primary in June. “I think [Senator] Angus King has done a fabulous job and I think Lucas is really capable of doing this. I don’t think Bruce Poliquin has; he really has gone completely into some other agenda.”
In late March, Donahue hosted a rally for St. Clair at her shop, North Light Gallery, in the heart of the district in Millinocket, Maine.
The third Democratic candidate, Craig Olson, is a business owner looking to represent working Mainers. A native Wisconsinite and bookstore owner, Olson was inspired to run against Poliquin in 2017 when the Republicans fought to end the Affordable Care Act. Olson, who contracted skin cancer several years ago, said he learned firsthand what it was like to be consumed by medical bills. Although his political experience does not extend further than holding positions on his town of Islesboro’s Board of Selectmen and its Planning Board, Olson argues that his experiences as a small-business owner and with the health-care system give him insight into what it is like to survive as an average Mainer.
A fourth candidate, the self-described progressive Jonathan Fulford, was present at the forum but has since withdrawn.
Despite the outpouring of support for the Democratic challengers at the Farmington forum, Poliquin’s supporters throughout the district say they are sticking with their candidate, even if they don’t show much enthusiasm.
“I don’t know if he’s ever been to Millinocket,” John Davis, a former paper mill worker, union representative and ex-Democrat who now serves as the town manager of Millinocket, noting that Poliquin will probably get his vote “because he’s got an ‘R’ next to his name.”

Even among some 2nd District millennials, a generation that has been relatively difficult for conservative Republican candidates to reel in across the country, Poliquin is garnering support.
“I voted for him because I was raised that way, in a conservative house,” said 20-year-old Jared Charrier, a Hermon resident who voted for both Trump and Poliquin in 2016. Charrier said he was unsure of whether he would vote for Poliquin again because he had not kept up with Poliquin’s policy decisions.
Charrier added that people from the 2nd District’s fondness of guns is one big difference they have with outsiders. Although Charrier favors some gun control, he has also earned a hunting learner’s permit and has received shooting lessons from his uncle, a trapper. (Related content: For many Mainers, gun rights are worth protecting)
“People like to go hunting in Maine. People love guns, I love guns. People from a city area don’t really understand this about people from the countryside. It’s not that I’m bashing them, it’s just that it’s so different,” said Charrier, who owns a Savage .308, a bolt-action rifle.
One of the greatest challenges the Democratic candidates face in their effort to unseat Poliquin is his fundraising lead. As of mid-April, Poliquin has amassed a significantly larger war chest than his opponents. According to data from the Federal Elections Commission, Poliquin raised more than $2.6 million by the end of March 2018, more than the combined total of his opponents; Golden has raised over $618,000, followed by St. Clair, who has raised just under $425,000 and Olson, who raised approximately $100,000.