Source 1:
What is the title of your source? | |
SELF-RESILIENCE AND SELF-RELIANCE THROUGH COLLEGIATE OUTDOOR ORIENTATION PROGRAMS | |
Copy and Paste the Abstract of your source. If no abstract is available, summarize in your own words what the source is about. | |
Getzinger, R.A. Self-resilience and self-reliance through collegiate outdoor orientation programs. MS in Physical Education Teaching, August 2021, 47pp (J. Starck)
Incoming freshman at a university are often faced with challenges of the unknown which can make the transition from home life difficult. Many universities offer transition programs to aid in the ease and feelings of belonging. One of those is an outdoor orientation program made available to incoming freshman at UWL. Often acknowledged in helping student transition is increased self-resilience and self-reliance. Self-resilience discusses how students rely on themselves to handle problems or a view of their own power versus another person’s. Self-reliance is how comfortable students feel depending on themselves versus another person. Therefore, the purpose of this study is to examine student’s self-reliance and self-resilience enrolled in an outdoor orientation program during their first semester at a university. Specifically, our research question is, do students who attend an outdoor orientation program have an increase in self-resilience and self-reliance? This study is timely due to COVID regulations and the need to help students transition successfully. KEYWORDS: outdoor orientation programs; self-resilience, self-reliance, college transition programs, challenge by choice |
|
In your own words, what is the author’s thesis (position)? | |
The author’s thesis is that participation in a non-traditional outdoor orientation program, specifically the First Flight program, has the potential to positively impact students’ self-resilience and self-reliance during their transition to college, especially in the context of challenges posed by the COVID-19 pandemic | |
In your own words, what are the subclaims made by the author? In other words, how does the author substantiate or defend their position? | |
Some of the sub-arguments state that these programs are valuable resources for incoming students as they aim to build social relationships, increase confidence, and create a sense of belonging among participants. The author further explains that the relationships formed during outdoor orientation programs can lead to long-term bonds among students, which can contribute to higher academic success rates and a greater likelihood of completing degrees in a shorter time frame. The sub-arguments go on to explain how the outdoor orientation programs can positively influence participants’ mental health and overall well-being.
The writer argues that high self-resilience is associated with characteristics such as self-efficacy, optimism, mindfulness, and the ability to overcome adversity. By exposing students to outdoor programs like rappelling or rock climbing, it helps build these traits. The author acknowledges the impact of COVID-19 on traditional face-to-face interactions during orientation programs. However, the author argues that such programs, even if adjusted, remain crucial in helping students make friendships, adapt to campus life, and gain confidence. |
|
Key quotes: list and cite (page ref.) at least three quotes from the source that you think may be useful for your essay. | |
Quote 1:
“Students who represent high self-reliance are confident in themselves, feel comfortable stepping out of their comfort zone, and have high self-esteem that helps them depend on themselves to overcome challenges.” (Page 5) Quote 2: “However, with low self-reliance, people tend to lack trust in themselves or their peers and struggle to escape their comfort zone.” (Page 5) Quote 3: “The negative effects of low self-reliance would be students who drop out of college, have low retention rates, struggle to find friends, or lack skills to overcome challenges they face.” (Page 5) |
|
What key sources does the author rely upon? List at least three. (Useful for further research) | |
Kitzrow, M. A. (2003). The mental health needs of today’s college students: Challenges and recommendations. Journal of Student Affairs Research and Practice, 41(1), 167–181. https:// doi.org/10.2202/1949-6605.1310
Liang, H. (2013). “An Eye for AN ‘I’ — an Insight INTO Emerson’s Thought of Self- Reliance.” Journal of Language Teaching and Research, 4(6)., doi: 10.4304/jltr.4.6.1351-1355 Luo, L. (1994). University transition: major and minor life stressors, personality characteristics and mental health. Psychological Medicine, 24(1), 81–87., doi: 10.1017/s0033291700026854 Wang, Y., Jing, X., Han, W. (2020). Positive and negative affect of university and college students during COVID-19 outbreak: a network-based survey. Int J Public Health 65, 1437-1443., doi: 10.1007/s00038-020-01483-3
|
Source 2:
What is the title of your source? |
Self-Reliance and Relations with Parents as Predictors of Anxiety and Depression in College Student |
Copy and Paste the Abstract of your source. If no abstract is available, summarize in your own words what the source is about. |
The transition to college can be stressful for young adults. Researchers have investigated factors related to students’ mental health as they adjust to college life. The current study examined the relative contributions of measures of self-reliance and parent relations to the prediction of anxiety and depression in college students. A sample of 153 college students enrolled in introductory psychology courses at a southeastern university completed the self-reliance and parent relations scales of the BASC-2 SRP-COL, the State Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI), and the Hamilton Depression Inventory (HDI). Multiple regression analyses indicated that self-reliance and parent relations were significant predictors of anxiety and depression with self-reliance scores making a greater contribution to the prediction of each of the outcome variables.
Keywords: anxiety, depression, college students, parent relations, self-reliance |
In your own words, what is the author’s thesis (position)? |
The author’s thesis is that self-reliance and the quality of relationships with parents can serve as predictors for anxiety and depression in college students. Furthermore believing that the two predictors may play a crucial role in the successful transition to college, suggesting that students high in self-reliance and with good parental support might make the most successful adaptation to the college environment. |
In your own words, what are the subclaims made by the author? In other words, how does the author substantiate or defend their position? |
The author uses several interconnected sub-claims that collectively underscore the role of psychological and social factors in shaping the college experience and mental well-being of students. Drawing on past research, the author highlights the profound impact of positive social support from parents, peers, and significant individuals, emphasizing its association with general adjustment to college, academic performance, and overall well-being. Furthermore, the author underscores the significance of self-esteem, positing that high self-esteem serves as a predictor of successful college adjustment, while low self-esteem is correlated with challenges such as anxiety, depression, and interpersonal difficulties. The author claims the concept of self-reliance, to be characterized as “self-confidence and assurance in one’s ability to make decisions,” the study distinguishes it as a unique measure of personal adjustment separate from self-esteem. The author acknowledges that the transition to college is a stressful period for young adults, involving challenges like living independently, increased academic demands, financial responsibilities, and social stressors. |
Key quotes: list and cite (page ref.) at least three quotes from the source that you think may be useful for your essay. |
1. “The hypothesis that self-reliance would make a larger contribution to the prediction of anxiety and depression than perceived relations with parents was supported.” (page 26) 2. Specifically, the prevalence of anxiety among college students has more than doubled from 6.7% in 2000 to 15.8% in 2015 [2,3] and the rates of depression for this age group have steadily risen as well from 10% in 2000 to 13.1% of college students being diagnosed and/or treated for depression in 2015 [2,3]. (page 24) 3. Self-reliance and college students’ psychosocial adjustment has not been investigated. The transition to college may lead to new experiences and challenges for many young adults. (page 25) |
What key sources does the author rely upon? List at least three. (Useful for further research) |
Eisenbarth, C. “Does self-esteem moderate the relations among perceived stress, coping, and depression?” College Student Journal, 46(1), 149-157. Mar 2012.
Mahmoud, J. S. R., Staten, R., Lennie, T. A., & Hall, L. A. “The relationships of coping, negative thinking, life satisfaction, social support, and selected demographics with anxiety of young adult college students” Journal of Child and Adolescent Psychiatric Nursing, 28, 97-108. 2015 Wartman, K.L., & Savage, M. “Parental involvement in higher education: Understanding the relationship among students, parents, and the institution.” ASHE Higher Education Report, 33(6), 1-125. 2008. Wright, S.L. & Perrone, K. M. An Examination of the Role of Attachment and Efficacy in Life Satisfaction The Counseling Psychologist August 2010 38: 796-823, first published on March 11, 2010.
|
Source 3:
What is the title of your source? |
Autonomy versus support: self-reliance and help-seeking for mental health problems in young people |
Copy and Paste the Abstract of your source. If no abstract is available, summarize in your own words what the source is about. |
Many young people with mental ill-health do not seek support, and developmental growth in self-reliance may be a barrier to help-seeking. Increasing autonomy is a positive developmental task for youth and a key aspect of resilience. This study examined the influence of perceived social support and resilience on the previously unexamined relationship between self-reliance and intentions to seek help from informal, professional, and self-help sources for mental health problems. |
In your own words, what is the author’s thesis (position)? |
The authors thesis involves testing several hypotheses related to the relationships between self-reliance, perceived social support, resilience, and intentions to seek help for mental health issues in young individuals. The authors believed that higher self-reliance would be associated with higher levels of self-help intentions. As well as higher self-reliance would correlate with lower perceived social support. |
In your own words, what are the subclaims made by the author? In other words, how does the author substantiate or defend their position? |
The authors make several sub-claims to support their position which include that despite the increasing autonomy and personal agency during adolescence and early adulthood (approximately 12–25 years), young people are paradoxically more vulnerable to mental health issues. Despite the high prevalence of mental health issues among young Australians, individuals aged 16–24 years are the least likely group to engage with professional help. The author points out the barriers to help-seeking, emphasizing individual-level factors such as a preference for self-reliance. Drawing on previous research, the author notes that extreme self-reliance, especially in individuals with severe depression, is associated with lower utilization of informal support. Such individuals may prefer to seek help independently, for example, through online sources. Lastly, the author claims that for young people facing adversity, self-reliance may be an expression of resilience, demonstrating the capacity to adapt and cope. However, it is noted that high levels of self-reliance, especially when rigid, may hinder the ability to seek appropriate support. |
Key quotes: list and cite (page ref.) at least three quotes from the source that you think may be useful for your essay. |
“ Higher self-reliance was associated with lower intentions to seek informal and professional help, as expected, but not with greater intentions for self-help.” (page 1)
“However, while self-reliance can be an effective strategy to cope with minor challenges, it may prevent individuals from seeking as well as accessing appropriate supports when required” (page 3) “The relationship between self-reliance and resilience, which is the ability to bounce back following adversity [34], is complex and largely linked to social influences. (page 3)” |
What key sources does the author rely upon? List at least three. (Useful for further research) |
Radez J, Reardon T, Creswell C, Orchard F, Waite P. Adolescents’ perceived barriers and facilitators to seeking and accessing professional help for anxiety and depressive disorders: a qualitative interview study. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiat. 2021 doi: 10.1007/s00787-020-01707-0.
van Zoonen K, Kleiboer A, Cuijpers P, Smit J, Penninx B, Verhaak P, Beekman A. Determinants of attitudes towards professional mental health care, informal help and self-reliance in people with subclinical depression. Int J Soc Psychiat. 2016;62(1):84–93. doi: 10.1177/0020764015597014. Quick JC, Joplin JR, Nelson DL, Quick JD. Behavioral responses to anxiety: self-reliance, counterdependence, and overdependence. Anxiety Stress Coping. 1992;5(1):41–54. doi: 10.1080/10615809208250486. |
Source 4:
What is the title of your source? |
SELF RELIANCE IN RELATION TO LEARNING STYLE OF HIGH SCHOOL STUDENTS |
Copy and Paste the Abstract of your source. If no abstract is available, summarize in your own words what the source is about. |
The present investigation was primarily designed to determine the relation of self reliance with the learning style of high school students. Descriptive survey method was employed. Random sampling technique was applied. 250 Students of two schools were selected randomly out of 106 government schools of Chandigarh. Learning style bears significant relationship with self reliance of high school students. Visual, Auditory, Tactile, Group and Individual learning styles bear significant relationship with self reliance of high school students. Kinaesthetic learning style bears no significant relationship with self reliance of high school students. |
In your own words, what is the author’s thesis (position)? |
The thesis revolves around investigating and understanding the relationship between self-reliance and the learning styles of high school students, without expressing a personal stance or opinion. |
In your own words, what are the subclaims made by the author? In other words, how does the author substantiate or defend their position? |
In the provided text, the author makes several sub-claims to contribute to the broader exploration of the relationship between self-reliance and learning styles in the context of high school students. Some sub-claims include that individuals have different learning styles, including visual, auditory, tactile, kinesthetic, and individual styles. The author provides a definition of self-reliance, characterizing it as an attitude with attributes such as assertiveness, optimism, independence, and emotional maturity. The author implies that understanding one’s learning style is crucial for efficient learning and processing of information. Different individuals may have different preferences in how they best acquire information. Tying with previous studies the author claims about the benefits of learning style instruction, suggesting that aligning study methods with one’s preferred learning style can lead to better outcomes, including improved grades and reduced anxiety. |
Key quotes: list and cite (page ref.) at least three quotes from the source that you think may be useful for your essay. |
“Self reliance is essentially an attitude which allows us to have a positive and real- istic perception of ourselves and our abilities. It is characterized by personal attributes such as assertiveness, optimism, enthusiasm, affection, pride, inde- pendence, trust, the ability to handle criticism and emotional maturity. “(page 1)
“Learning style bears the positive correlation with self reliance which means that the specific learning style which is adopted by the individual instils the self-reliance in him regarding the understanding of information and instructions and his retention power. The world is likely to believe in man who believes in himself, provided he shows that his self reliance is grounded upon a true appraisal and is well managed. “(page 2) “Self reliance is the first essentiality if a person wants to succeed. Learning style which if managed and motivated correctly can inspire an individual excel with confidence in anything he tries to do. “(page 2) |
What key sources does the author rely upon? List at least three. (Useful for further research) |
Alam, R. (1987) Self Reliance and self confidence. Zaheen Publications
Coman and Heaver, J. (1998) Knowing Learning Style Can Improve Self Confidence Of Developmental Writers. Educational Journal,Vol 5, (pp 212- 215). Kaur, G. (2009) Self reliance as related to Achievement Motivation, Unpublished M.ed. Dissertation, Panjab University |
Source 5:
What is the title of your source? |
Becoming Self-Reliant: A Lesson I Learned From College |
Copy and Paste the Abstract of your source. If no abstract is available, summarize in your own words what the source is about. |
The narrative highlights the transformative journey of a college student who initially grapples with academic and personal challenges, including weight gain and social struggles. After encountering Ralph Waldo Emerson’s essay on self-reliance, the student undergoes a profound shift, embracing autonomy and making lifestyle changes. The essay reflects on the importance of self-reliance, resilience, and critical thinking cultivated during the college experience, illustrating how these lessons contribute to personal growth, well-being, and a newfound sense of confidence in navigating adulthood. |
In your own words, what is the author’s thesis (position)? |
The thesis is that college experience is a transformative period that presents challenges but also provides an opportunity for personal growth. The author believes self-reliance is a crucial life skill, which allows one to navigate life’s challenges |
In your own words, what are the subclaims made by the author? In other words, how does the author substantiate or defend their position?. |
The author supports their thesis through several subclaims that include description of College Challenges: experience, such as tough academics, social pressures, and the need to succeed. The author uses personal experiences during the initial college years, highlighting struggles with academics, loneliness, and health issues, including weight gain. The author introduces the influence of Ralph Waldo Emerson’s essay on self-reliance, quoting Emerson’s assertion that discontent is the lack of self-reliance. Lastly, the author undergoes self-reflection, questioning the source of unhappiness and realizing the need for self-reliance. |
Key quotes: list and cite (page ref.) at least three quotes from the source that you think may be useful for your essay. |
“Becoming self-reliant was one of the hardest skills that I had to develop in my lifetime, but it is invaluable as I navigate life as an adult.”
“But another aspect of my joy came from being self-reliant and seeing the results of the hard work and willpower required to achieve my goals of weight loss and a healthy lifestyle.” “Instead, I learned to persevere and become self-reliant, which resulted in figuring out how to eat properly and take care of my health, manage my time, succeed in my classes, fulfill personal obligations, and do whatever I had to in order to survive.” |
What key sources does the author rely upon? List at least three. (Useful for further research) |
While no sources were mentioned, there was a few references from Emerson, Ralph Waldo, 1803-1882. Self-Reliance. White Plains, N.Y. :Peter Pauper Press, 1967 |