Franz Kafka is known for creating disturbed and unsettling literary art; something uncomfortable that would cut through the ice. In The Judgement, Kafka introduces an unnamed character in St. Petersburg who is living an unstable life while his childhood acquaintance in Prague, Georg Bendemann, sends him letters of inconsequential news. The friend may represent one of Kafka’s identities and throughout the whole story, the relationship between the unnamed friend and Georg seem to be blurred. Kafka insinuates that there are multiple sides to a person and that every single being will never be identical; one cannot judge a person based on stability.
The unnamed friend is the opposite of Georg and he had virtually fled away from Prague to this foreign country with no real ties and social dealings in the local colony of St. Petersburg. The act of fleeing away from home is the result to a new life and experience. The friend was discontented with his development at home so he discovered Russia and isolated himself. Kafka can relate to this in his writing and he isolated himself from the outside world and decided to compose a literary work in one night.
The friend is characterized to have a disease that nears his death at such a young age.
“..whose sallow complexion seemed to indicate a developing disease.” (57)
“…your friend is going to the dogs in his Russia, three years ago he was already yellow enough to be dumped out,..” (71)
His disease may have occurred during his stay at St. Petersburg and this embodies a sign of weakness and that the end is near. Living in St. Petersburg becoming a bachelor for good depicts that there is no progress with his life. The experience he wanted to encounter was a complete downfall due to his own business stagnating. The full exotic beard and his poorly concealing face indicates that he is not taking care of himself and is slowly letting himself go. Maybe he does not have the strength and power to succeed because he needs to have someone to depend on. The reason Georg did not mention his fiancee to him was because he may be envious of him or feel pressured. The friend was struggling to live by himself while Georg was this man of stability and success. Although you can question Georg’s superego because the power of his father’s words had led to his own downfall.
“So now you know what else there was in the world besides you, previously you only knew about yourself! You were truly an innocent child, but you were even more truly a diabolical man! And therefore know: I hereby condemn you to death by drowning!” (71)
Kafka explains the judgement of the two men reflected in this story. You cannot judge a man by his own success of living because every being is significantly differential. Georg having a fiancee and a successful business gave him the ability to have a stable life but his moral sense had overpowered him when he committed suicide. The friend living an unstable life in Russia lacks motivation for success due to his fleeing away from home, the health condition he encounters and his isolation from others. One cannot be successful without the help and support of others.