At any given hour of the day, a Manhattan or Brooklyn-bound L train generally looks the same—crowded. The benches are almost always full, the cars are loud with conversation and the platforms are bustling with musicians playing tunes ranging from banjo-plucking folk to synchronized percussion.
Commuters who rely on this train daily in neighborhoods which are largely disconnected from other subway lines, are hoping that they will soon reap the benefits of its closure. Many Brooklyn locals are anticipating that the Metropolitan Transit Authority’s plan to close the L train will actually help them afford to live in trendy areas such as Williamsburg and Bushwick, which have recently grown in popularity.
The subway line, which runs from 14th Street and Eighth Avenue in Manhattan all the way to Rockaway Parkway in Canarsie, sees over 400,000 riders daily.
Due to extensive damage from Hurricane Sandy back in 2012, the MTA recently announced that the L train will shut down between Manhattan and Bedford Avenue in Williamsburg in January 2019 for 18 months so that it can be properly repaired.
Although the MTA’s plan will be highly inconvenient for some, most locals do not plan to relocate to other parts of New York. In fact, many residents are actually expecting to see their rents decrease as a result of the closure.
“I’m really hoping that the L shutting down will help decrease my rent. I can’t imagine people wanting to move to a place where there’s no subway. But as for me, I love this area and I don’t want to live anywhere else,” said Megan Lansky, 32.
“Taking a shuttle bus will definitely suck,” she added. “But commuting sucks in general, so I guess it’s not that bad.”
Lansky currently shares a four-bedroom apartment on the southeast end of Bushwick for a combined total of $2,350 per month.
Stephanie Pearson, 24, agreed with Lansky.
“I hope rent goes down here,” she said. “It makes sense that a remote area would become cheaper. Perhaps, with people moving out because of the shutdown, gentrification could reverse itself.”
Pearson lives on Williamsburg’s east end, in a loft that she shares with five other roommates for a total of $3,000 a month.
In fact, a rent decrease in the affected neighborhoods appears to be statistically likely, according to a rent analysis by FiveThirtyEight. The source claims, “The shutdown should shave about $200 to $450 off the rent of the typical Williamsburg one-bedroom—until the repair work is done, anyway.”
Although residents remain hopeful that their rents will in fact see a sharp decrease in the coming years, they are still left with the problem of getting into Manhattan without the L train. Many neighborhoods along the L line do not have other subway lines available, leaving many commuters wondering how they will be able to substitute for this integral mode of transit.
While Lansky is able to take the J train into Manhattan as an alternative, Pearson is rather isolated from other subway lines.
“Where I live in Williamsburg, the L train is pretty much it. Walking a mile to the J or M really isn’t realistic for my daily commute. I’m hoping the MTA will have shuttle buses, but I can’t say that I’m looking forward to riding one every day,” she said.
She added, “And paying for a daily cab ride to and from the subway plus a monthly unlimited metro card? Are you kidding me?”
This is the reality that many Brooklyn residents will be facing in two years. The question of whether or not it is worth it to pay extra for a lesser commute time will be lingering. But perhaps the MTA will take note of this inconvenience, and consider giving some of these neighborhoods more subway options, especially considering the L train sees some of the highest daily commuter rates in the entire subway system.
Jeffrey Schleider, founder of Miron Properties and a Williamsburg local, commented on the neighborhood’s disconnect from other subway lines, saying, “There’s a larger transportation issue…Hopefully what will come out of this is that they will continue to keep the additional forms of transportation [needed to help during the closure] whether it’s an express bus or express ferry.”
So whether it be a rent decrease, or the MTA ultimately realizing that the most popular neighborhoods in Brooklyn should be a bit more connected to the rest of the subway system, residents are hopeful that some good may eventually come out of the L train shutdown which looms in the near future.