The Lies We Tell in the Exam Room
http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/04/22/the-lies-we-tell-in-the-exam-room/?_r=0
This article discussed the lies that both doctors and patients tell regarding health. It explained that these lies are part of the health care problem in this nation. The author, a primary health care physician, starts off by telling us that they’ve been asked to lie about certain aspects of a patients condition and that it’s hard to know when to draw the line. This article explained how there is rarely complete honesty between the doctor and the patient. Zuger, the author of this article, says that “complete honesty suffuses relationships with insurers, too. But surveys have repeatedly confirmed that many doctors habitually tell insurers blatant lies on behalf of their patients — and feel perfectly fine, even righteous, about doing so.” There is a great debate over whether or not the physician should lie to insurance companies if it would help the patient in the end. Some people believe that lying to the insurance company is perfectly fine if it is for the greater good of the patient, others disagree saying it will only cause insurance companies to tighten their purse strings even tighter.
This article relates to the truth by describing some doctor/patient relationships, and the relationship of both to insurance companies. The author of this article, Dr. Abigail Zuger, admits to sometimes, on request, giving patients sick notes until Wednesday, so they could run errands, even if they will be healthy by Monday. Of course this is a little white lie, and is not a big deal because it is not hurting anyone, but this article also talks about people taking advantage of the doctors niceness, which relates to the thrill of cheating and lying. In this case, that is where telling the truth becomes important, to show that people cannot constantly take advantage of another person, therefore, if patients go overboard, Dr. Zuger writes them the sick note until Monday. This article also talks about a debatable topic, where it is hard to tell which one is best, telling the truth or lying. The author gives the example of the fact that an insurance company will not pay for a certain test or a procedure before the patient has a doctor’s diagnoses. This may lead to patient’s health and life being at risk. Nicolas Tavaglione and Dr. Samia A. Hurst, at the Institute for Biomedical Ethics at Geneva University Medical School in Switzerland, say that it is okay and it is even encouraged to sign papers for the insurance companies because the number one priority should be helping the person in need. However, ethicists disagree because too many doctors may be doing that, which strains the insurance companies, and makes it unfair for other people. There are many issues where it is questionable whether it’s good to tell the truth or not. Sometimes, you really have to base it on the situation, weigh the pros and cons, and then make the decision to tell the truth or to tell a lie.