This paper seemed easier to write than the first since this assignment felt more structured. Still, the intro received criticism. I knew that the thesis did not capture the entire essence of the paper very well but I felt that could have been worked on later. Some of the problems that appeared in the previous paper appeared in this one as well. The solutions are simple yet complicated. I feel so close to writing a high-grade paper yet so far. I’ll probably have to seek outside assistance to improve on the papers (e.g. SACC). Or, read over a number of successful thematic essays.
The biggest problem seems to be fitting every idea in. Multiple ideas are connected to each other which in turn connect to other ones, each needing to be explained. It seems nigh impossible to fit everything into one or two sentences, the thesis statement. The only real answer is to isolate and communicate only one or two ideas but that does not give a full enough picture and does an injustice to the reader. All the meanwhile evidence has to support the ideas. I’m not sure how this can all be done in an essay from a narrow handful of literary texts. The simplest answer is to change the thesis to fit the texts, not try to fit the texts into the thesis. This is less fun but it’s probably a better approach.
Revisions, revisions, revision… I’m wondering if this is what a writer spends most of his time on. If that’s the case I don’t envy one. Why dwell on the same thing for so much time? Moving forward is the right way to go. If you’re spending so much time on the same thing with relatively few results it’s better to move on and come back again. That’s my philosophy anyway. Time is too precious to waste.
i think that what sucks about writing is that if you wanna write something good you have to spend A LOT of time on it….taking each sentence one by one…then each paragraph and making sure it makes sense…then the entire thing and making sure it flows…it depends on how motivated you are. if you spend the time I’m sure you will get that high grade you want..its just a matter of giving it time and attention
Ah, revisions…I wonder if each revision can actually be thought of as creating a new essay (or “thought experiment”)? If I remember correctly, you’re writing on Crane, a poem that I often find so rich that it overwhelms me. You might want to pick your favorite moment and explore why and how it works for you and perhaps that might help narrow your response?