On any given morning, residents flock to Astoria Park to begin their day. Joggers put on their running shoes and take in the brisk air as they make their way down the sidewalk on Shore Boulevard. Toddlers strapped in their strollers enjoy the site of the barges making their way down the East River and under the Hell Gate Bridge. A dozen dogs of all sizes run through the grass playing with each other. One dog runs towards the street chasing a speeding car, driven by a man who is running late for work.
Soon the man driving that car may need to change his routine. In August of 2015 Assemblywoman Aravella Simotas wrote a letter to the New York State Department of Transportation (DOT), proposing to close Shore Boulevard to all through traffic, with the exception of emergency vehicles, due to the amount of vehicle related accidents that have occurred over the decades, as well has noise violations coming from the busy street. Residents who utilize the 1.1-mile stretch of road oppose the proposal, claiming it will take away from the traditions of Astoria residents.
“The truth is that many residents take their families over there to enjoy the waterfront view,” Peter Argyris, creator of a petition against the assemblywoman’s proposal, writes on his change.org page. “This is a tradition that has been happening for generations.” Argyris’ petition, titled “We Say No to Banning Cars on Shore Boulevard at Astoria Park” has over one thousand signatures.
“We all have memories of driving down Shore Boulevard,” Says another resident, Sal Feola, Jr., who feels closing the road will ruin the Astoria tradition. On weekends and days off, the local teenagers and young adults would drive down to Astoria Park and hang out by the river.
A Proposal to Make Shore Boulevard a Safer Place
Assemblywoman Simotas’ proposal is not the first to address the problems of Shore Boulevard. A representative for the Queens Community Board 1 stated that in the 1980s the DOT and community leaders did a walk-about of Short Boulevard in an attempt to find a solution to the traffic issues. At that time, the DOT decided the best solution to the speeding would be to add speed bumps along the road, running from Ditmars Boulevard to Astoria Park South.
“What it really should be is a pedestrian walkway,” Simotas told DNAinfo.com. “There would be a lot more people who could utilize and enjoy that area.”
Though the petition does call for a closing of Shore Boulevard to all vehicular traffic, other variations are being considered, according to Queens Community Board 1. One suggested alternative would change the road from a two-way street to a one-way with a bicycle lane.
Death and Disaster in Astoria Park
According to the New York Police Department’s 114th Precinct, between August 2011 and June 2015, 18 traffic accidents occurred on Shore Boulevard, four of which caused injury. One such accident occurred in April 2014 near 20th Avenue, when an SUV carrying four plowed through a brick wall, plunging into the East River at around 4:00 A.M. All passengers escaped with minor injuries.
Betty Jean Diblasio was not so lucky. A driver ran a stop sign at Ditmars Boulevard, killing the 21-year-old this past June. The driver fled the scene, turning himself in the next day.
A “Nightclub” to Many
The straight stretch of road connecting two main roads is not only a haven for speeding drivers and drag racing motorcyclists, but also for late night partygoers.
Local residents describe Shore Boulevard as a “nightclub,” where people flock at all hours of the night into the early morning to dance, drink, smoke pot and blast music from their cars.

Fisherman enjoy midday activities at Shore Boulevard, while a local Police Officer from the 114th Precinct patrols the area.
“There has always been a noise issue at Astoria Park,” long-time resident Michael DeSimini says. He recalls times during his teenage years when he and his friends would drive down to Shore Boulevard. “We would hang out there until two or three in the morning sometimes.” As a teenager, DeSimini enjoyed the times he spent with friends by the East River, but now as an adult, he realizes the problems that it causes. “Its an annoyance to the older residence and does cause a safety issue,” he says.
Due to its secluded location between and beyond the Hell Gate and the Robert F. Kennedy Bridges, the area is a haven for nighttime festivities. The noise problem was addressed by former New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg in his “Operation Silent Night” program, which started in late 2002. The program, as described in a press release, was implemented “to combat loud and excessive noise.” The program targeted 24 areas throughout the five boroughs that were deemed “plagued by chronic and disruptive problems like noise.”
Opposition Despite the Complaints and Agreement Despite the Traditions
Despite the traffic and noise complaints of many residents, the proposal to close Shore Boulevard was met with much opposition. The petition created by Peter Argyris says that if the proposal to close the road is passed, it will “ruin…tradition and decrease the quality of life in the neighborhoods.”
Sal Feola, Jr. shares Argyris’ point-of-view, saying that closing Shore Boulevard will take away from the appeal of Astoria Park.
“I like driving on Shore Boulevard,” Feola, Jr. says. “If I am going to visit the waterfront, I am going to drive there.” He believes that closing the roadway would make viewing the roadway inconvenient. “It’s part of life in Astoria.”
Michael DeSimini, however, feels that despite these traditions, closing Shore Boulevard will benefit the community. He agrees that driving down to Shore Boulevard is a part of life in Astoria but that the well-being of the community is more important.
“There are so many accidents there and the kids hanging out drinking and doing drugs just creates an unsafe environment,” DeSimini says. Closing Shore Boulevard, in his opinion, is a crucial step to improving the quality of life in Astoria. “I know a lot of people would feel better living here if they didn’t have to worry about being struck by a drunk driver after their evening run.”
Discussion Arises Amongst Residents and Officials
After drafting his petition against the assemblywoman’s proposal, Peter Argyris received a letter from Simotas, requesting a meeting to discuss his concerns of her proposal. Shortly after, Planning Board 1 member Tony Meloni wrote an open letter on givemeastoria.com supporting Argyris’ petition.
“Probably 80% or the people who come to visit Astoria Park and Shore Boulevard …come by car,” Meloni’s letter reads. He claims the reasoning behind the proposed closure are “nonsensical,” stating that the drag racing, crime and noise issues are minimal and are not cause for concern.” He goes on to argue that closing that stretch of road because of noise pollution would just move the issues to the nearby residential streets. He ends his letter by saying “please leave our ‘Miracle Mile’… alone.”
The Finalized Decision
Meloni’s letter and Argyris’ petition were part of the discussion held at the Town Hall Meeting in late October of 2015. Assemblywoman Simotas, along with Councilman Costa Constantinides and the State DOT ran the meeting to discuss the proposal.

A view of Manhattan and the Robert F. Kennedy Triboro Bridge from Shore Boulevard.
After the meeting, Argyris’ posted an update to his change.org petition, stating “it was unanimously decided… that Shore Boulevard will not close.” He was invited to speak at the Astoria Civic Association Meeting that was held in November, where he presented the final updated petition to the Commissioner of the DOT, Polly Trottenberg.
According to Argyris’ petition, Commissioner Trottenberg declared that there are no plans to close Shore Boulevard and that the DOT will continue to look into enhancing safety issue in the area.