Jackson’s Blog “Kiddie Lit” Preface and Chapter 1

The Author, Beverly Leon Clark, underwent an enormous change of opinion regarding her thought on children’s literature.  She mentioned that as a graduate student she “wouldn’t be caught dead reading children’s literature.” (Clark, Kiddie Lit, Preface).  Clark’s friend, who became president of the Children’s Literature Association, was influential in changing her mind about how she viewed that genre of literature.

The author ironically titles her book Kiddie Lit, highlighting the juxtaposition of the word kiddie- a “condescending and more than a little supercilious” term with the abbreviation lit- short for literature, a classic and noteworthy piece of written text (Clark, Chapter 1).  Children hate being referred to as kids, or even worse kiddies, because they feel demeaned.  Likewise, literature, or “lit” as Clark writes, infers higher level, complex prose – something that seems beyond the comprehension and appreciation of children.   By no means is this Clark’s intention from the title.

Another unlikely comparison is introduced when Clark goes on to compare women in patriarchal society to children.  She states the fact that they are both often ignored and overlooked.  However, Clark points out that there is one important distinction to be made about children:  where male children can grow out of childhood the females may grow to be women, yet are stuck in their lesser, societal roles.

Historically, women like children were viewed as “innocent, fragile, temptable, and therefore in need of molding.”  (Acocella, Little People)   Times are changing.  People’s attitudes toward women and children have changed as well.  Likewise, people’s attitudes toward Kiddie Lit have changed.  Clark states “My aim here is not to be comprehensive but to offer comprehensive case studies, in-depth analysis that, in concert, reveal the complexity of changing attitude towards children and children’s literature.” (Clark, Chapter 1).

Jackson’s Blog on “Little People”

This article goes to great lengths to compare the theories and research of several major sociologists and anthropologists on when we started treating children like children.  At one point they were viewed as mini-adults with responsibilities and roles to play.  Then they became “innocent, fragile, and temptable” beings (Joan Acocella, Little People) who needed protection and guidance.  One might ask- what sparked this transition from independent being, to practically helpless individual?  The author suggests that in reality kids have always been kids.  Society and it’s flaws have determined whether or not they had the freedom to act like children.  Infant mortality, poverty, illegitimacy, religion, even marriage norms all contributed to the quality of life of children throughout history.

I found that I appreciated the author’s perspective and sense of irony when he wrote “while disposing of your child was easy, getting rid of your spouse was next to impossible.” (Joan Acocella, Little People).  After all, what did it matter if one author believed children were too coddled and another disagreed.  Societal factors such as; poverty, fear of social stigma, and religious constraints caused women to abandon or dispose permanently of their children.  And that was okay.  Yet, marriage was to be endured regardless of abuse, infidelity or incompatibility.

Joan Acocella makes sure that the reader not only remembers the continuity or sentimentalist theory, but that historical factors determined the lifestyle of children.

How to Post

1. Log in to your blogs@baruch account.

2. Navigate to our class site  blogs.baruch.cuny.edu/childishness

3. Click New Post or Add Post.

4. Type in your post (or cut and paste from a word document).

5. Ignore the categories sections.

6. Add 2-3 tags.    To add a tag, write a word or phrase in the “tag” box,  and click add.   To add the second tag,  repeat that process.   A tag is a word or phrase that you want to be associated with your post.  So if you write about the casual cops, you might use the tags  “walking” and “police”.  I imagine that most of you will use “walking,” which is great.  But you should probably one or two other tags specific to your post.

7. Clickpublish.”  If you don’t click “publish,” your post will not show on the cite.

POST GROUPS

This information will also be available at the bottom of the schedule of assignments.

 

GROUP A

Asano, Oriana
Ayala, Kimberly
Bauer, Corey
Chancy, Natasia
Chang, Jaime
Chen, Mason
Cummings, Chiffon
Digrazia, Christopher
Dilillo, Nicole
Frost, Laura
GROUP B

Kovalchuk, Artem
Zeng, Sherry
Urrutia, Raymond
Gomes, Oishi
Hughes, Stephanie
Jimenez, Kristine
Lee, Jasmine
Lee, William
Marienfeld, Jackson
Mohan, James
GROUP C
Ng, Donald
Parietti, Charles
Perez, Jason
Ross, Joshua
Shallcross, Annalea
Siragusa, Nikko  
Sooklall, Serena
Torres, Jaclyn
Vasquez, Vanessa
White, Dominique
Wong, Christopher
Wu, Maggie

Readings

P1060745

 

remember the readings for Monday are the “preface” and chapter one to Kiddie Lit AND the NYT article “Little People”.  The links should work on the schedule of assignments/readings page.