Frederick Douglass and Discourse on the Logic of Language Comparison – Daniel Kennedy

One of the first things in Philip’s poem that helps me further understand Douglass’s struggle is when she begins by saying “English is my mother tongue” and explains how it is not a foreign language. This idea reminds me of how slaves, like Douglass, are often born in the United States, and how the harsh conditions in which they work happen right here in their own country. Similarly, I am reminded of how lives of everyday Americans, such as going to school, working an industrial job with living wages, and other factors of life are familiar to the slaves. Although Douglass works on plantations for much of his life, he still understands how everyday Americans live.

Philips then goes on to say that slaves are deprived of an education, so that they “cannot speak to each other,” reminding me of how Douglass was not allowed to learn much more than what Sophia Auld originally taught him when they first met. Without being educated, slaves would not be literate, and therefore would not be able to rebel against their owners and conjure up ways to escape the harsh conditions in which they live. Furthermore, when Philips mentions the belief that “white males have larger brains” than women and blacks, and that they are superior beings, this shows me the entire idea behind slavery. It was based solely off of the unproven belief that some people are superior to others, and therefore have the rights to rule them. This is similar to the idea in Douglass’s narrative that not only are people born into slavery because of their race, and other factors that they cannot control, but also that they may feel that if slaves become free, they will begin to take jobs previously performed by supposedly better people.

2 thoughts on “Frederick Douglass and Discourse on the Logic of Language Comparison – Daniel Kennedy

  1. I think it is very interesting that you tie the idea of how technically Frederick Douglass was born in the United States, but he was still treated in very harsh conditions similar to the everyday Americans who worked during the time of industrialization. Many people tend to forget that tons of slaves were actually born in the US, but they were not regarded as citizens and had no rights. Like you mentioned, the white men use to believe they were more superior to the blacks and women, so the blacks and women were treated as inferior.

  2. It is interesting to think about the fact that a lot of slaves were born in this country and were then treated poorly inside their own country. Additionally, I agree that the make believe idea of white male superiority was the driving force to slavery.

Comments are closed.