Argument Essay

Memorials are a way for societies to honor and remember the past, whether it be the lives of individuals, historical events, or shared cultural experiences. They serve as tangible representations of shared values, histories, and identities, and can help to shape the way that a society understands and remembers its past. However, the purpose of a memorial can vary greatly depending on the context in which it is created and the audience for which it is intended.

In an interview with NPR, historian Simon Schama discusses the characteristics of successful memorials. He argues that the most effective memorials are those that are able to express and convey the emotions and values of the society that created them. He cites the Vietnam Veterans Memorial in Washington D.C. as an example of a successful memorial, noting that it allows people to experience the loss and sacrifice of the war in a personal and individual way. Schama also emphasizes the importance of the physical location of a memorial, as well as the use of symbolism and storytelling to convey meaning.He highlights the need for memorials to be inclusive and to honor diverse perspectives and experiences, rather than promoting a singular narrative or ideology.

A similar perspective is offered by an article from the University of Southern California, which discusses the role of memorials in helping communities to confront and heal from difficult or traumatic events. The article argues that memorials can serve as a way for communities to remember and honor the victims of violence or injustice, while also providing a space for reflection and dialogue about the events that took place. This can help to facilitate a process of healing and reconciliation, as well as promoting a sense of community and shared purpose.

However, the purpose of a memorial can also be more controversial and divisive, as is often the case with memorials related to the Confederacy in the United States. An article from CNN discusses the various options that communities have for dealing with Confederate monuments, including removal, contextualization, or relocation. The article notes that these decisions are often accompanied by significant debate and emotion, as they can be seen as either honoring or erasing aspects of a community’s history. The article also highlights the importance of listening to a diverse range of perspectives and engaging in dialogue when considering the future of these types of memorials.

A memorial may also be more personal, as is the case with the planned statue of Ruth Bader Ginsburg in Brooklyn, New York. As reported in an article from Curbed, the statue is being commissioned by Governor Andrew Cuomo as a tribute to Ginsburg’s legacy and her impact on the legal system. The statue will be the first of a woman in the borough and will be part of a larger effort to increase representation of women in public art in New York City. In this case, the purpose of the memorial is to honor the life and achievements of an individual, as well as to recognize the significance of her contributions to society.

In conclusion, the purpose of a memorial can vary greatly depending on the context in which it is created and the audience for which it is intended. However, some common themes emerge, including the need to express and convey the emotions and values of a society, to facilitate a process of healing and reconciliation, and to honor and remember the past. It is important for societies to carefully consider the purpose of a memorial and to ensure that it reflects the diverse perspectives and experiences of its members.